model-writtenrun 229 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Bharath Rupireddy proposed reporting the current index and parallel leader PID in pg_stat_progress_vacuum so users could diagnose slow index vacuuming, with each worker exposing its own row #1; Satyanarayana Narlapuram flagged stale index reporting, the leader-PID API, and its SQL type #2.
- Antonin Houska offered independent infrastructure for nested command progress, motivated by REPACK rebuilding indexes, and intended to pursue it in the REPACK series; that attachment was not incorporated into the vacuum feature #3.
- Sami Imseih argued for retaining one row per command and aggregating worker identities into arrays #4; Bharath favored using existing per-backend progress slots rather than introducing shared-memory machinery #5, and Sami supplied the SQL aggregation implementation with index-reporting fixes #7.
- Bharath refined the array documentation #8, but Sami demonstrated that pg_stat_activity permissions could hide leader_pid and break aggregation for unprivileged readers #9; they discussed exposing or tracking leader_pid directly, while Michael Paquier defended the existing visibility restrictions #10 #11 #12.
- Michael advocated individual worker rows to accommodate richer progress details and future parallelization strategies #13; Sami defended command-level rows and proposed a separate worker view #14 #15, while Bharath favored one view and separate index block counters because heap progress must survive multi-pass index vacuuming #16 #18.
- Bharath implemented the per-worker design as two patches, one identifying the current index and another reporting B-tree blocks #21, then removed the redundant leader_pid column after discussion with Michael #22; Michael endorsed the resulting design and requested combining the related features for landing #23.
- Sami continued to question mixing command-level and backend-local counters #24, while Masahiko Sawada supported per-backend rows and explained that a broader job-specific progress-view design would require infrastructure beyond this patch #25.
- Bharath merged index identification and block progress and added a separate patch removing IndexVacuumInfo.report_progress #26; Sami conceded the interface choice, reviewed the code positively, and identified documentation and comment errors #27, which Bharath corrected #28.
- Shihao Zhong tested sequential and parallel B-tree and GIN behavior and supplied injection-point and TAP-test patches #29; Michael raised concerns about proliferating bespoke progress tests #30, so Shihao withdrew those additions in favor of work on a general testing framework #31, which Bharath supported #32.
- Michael tested the feature, shortened its documentation and comments, and posted the final patch while declining to remove report_progress because external access methods might need it #34; Sami accepted that version with a documentation suggestion #35, Shihao confirmed serial, parallel, and parallel autovacuum tests #36, and Bharath accepted retaining the flag and the simplified patch #38.
- Michael committed #34 as 1378aa1343, adding the catalog version bump and final commit message with only documentation whitespace changes beyond rebasing; his closing message confirmed the landing and explained that the suggested extra worker-lifetime sentence was redundant #39.
- At the thread's close, per-index identification and B-tree block progress had landed, the bespoke tests had been withdrawn for separate framework work, and removal of report_progress had been left out to preserve access-method control #31 #34 #39.