model-writtenrun 252 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Nathan Bossart opened the thread with two cleanups: deleting the obsolete tas() fallback and replacing redundant HAS_TEST_AND_SET checks with TAS checks; he also questioned the clarity of the platform requirements documented in s_lock.h #1.
- Tristan Partin endorsed the proposal #2, while Tom Lane requested explicit missing-platform error handling and initially opposed removing HAS_TEST_AND_SET for compatibility reasons #3; Kirill Reshke identified stale tas.s references in the build files #4.
- Nathan explained why the header obscured what a new platform must implement #5 and supplied a combined revision that retained a centralized HAS_TEST_AND_SET definition #6.
- Tom reframed the contract as requiring either a platform S_LOCK or a TAS implementation supporting the default S_LOCK, supplied a replacement patch, suggested omitting the default helper when unnecessary, and withdrew his objection to removing HAS_TEST_AND_SET after checking its uses #7; Nathan accepted that direction #8.
- Nathan restored the two original cleanups and added a third patch documenting and enforcing the platform contract, removing obsolete historical comments #9; the next revision also incorporated Kirill's build-file cleanup request #10.
- Nathan noticed that a custom S_LOCK need not provide TAS_SPIN because only the default s_lock() helper uses it #11, then corrected the series by conditionally compiling that helper and relaxing the TAS_SPIN requirement #12.
- Nathan also proposed broader simplification through unlocked tests and compiler intrinsics, but left those ideas outside the submitted series pending research and benchmarking #9.
- After the May-to-September gap, Nathan committed the first component of #12 with an additional empty assembly-file deletion as 2079be3311, and the second component with only whitespace and rebase differences as 3e9bc39c5d, announcing both landings in #13.
- Nathan resubmitted the remaining platform-contract patch with test-call fixes and removed the restriction against defining both TAS and S_LOCK, explaining that the platform's S_LOCK simply takes precedence #13.
- The remaining patch landed with an identical code diff and a shortened commit message, crediting Tom as co-author, in d9b5a63f49; Nathan's final message confirms that all three submitted components were committed #14.