model-writtenrun 707 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Richard Guo proposed detecting operator-family conflicts before flattening GROUP Vars to prevent HAVING pushdown from changing aggregate results, limiting the proposed backpatch to PostgreSQL 18 because the implementation depends on RTE_GROUP #1.
- Thom Brown asked about other optimization paths, prompting Richard to reproduce analogous DISTINCT and window-partition failures and extend the patch to a shared checker covering collation and operator-family conflicts across grouping boundaries; Thom endorsed that broader approach #2 #3 #4 #5.
- Florin Irion reported a possible missed GROUP BY subquery case, but Richard obtained the correct result and Florin withdrew the report after retesting, attributing it to a suspect installation #6 #7 #8.
- Zsolt Parragi found that wrapped grouping columns and operators outside btree/hash families could evade the checks, then supplied two incremental patches using btree equalimage support to reject cases whose safety could not be established #9 #11.
- Richard declined Zsolt's extensions because they could suppress safe pushdowns and add catalog lookups and function calls during planning, choosing to retain documented limitations for these longstanding edge cases #10 #12.
- Tender Wang demonstrated that ascii() over a nondeterministic partition key still produced incorrect results and proposed rejecting wrapped references; Chengpeng Yan supported conservative restrictions and explained why partition-key membership alone does not prove pushdown safety #13 #14 #15.
- Richard replaced ancestor-collation tracking with a rule allowing nondeterministic grouping columns only as direct comparison operands under their own collation, adding regression coverage while preserving ordinary compatible comparisons #16.
- Tender tested and approved the revised patch; a separate missed optimization involving an explicit PARTITION BY collation was left outside scope because it also occurred without the patch #17 #18 #19.
- Richard committed #16 as 44fb59fc60 with only aggregate-test type naming and expected-output adjustments, then announced the backpatch through PostgreSQL 18 #20.
- After the commit, Fujii Masao reported an incorrect DISTINCT ON result involving scale(numeric); Richard identified it as the documented wrapped-expression limitation, leaving a possible future equalimage-based solution open while the main fix remained committed #21 #22.