model-writtenrun 5 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Srinath Reddy Sadipiralla reported that concurrent logical-slot creation could write duplicate activation records and break decoding, proposing a second status check after reacquiring LogicalDecodingControlLock plus an injection-point test in #1.
- Masahiko Sawada accepted the diagnosis and simplified comments and test synchronization in #3, preserving the original locking strategy.
- While reviewing concurrency, Masahiko found additional standby races involving WAL-replayed deactivation and promotion, and added a second patch that rechecks decoding status after slot creation in #4.
- Srinath approved the standby fix and suggested informing the primary about standby-private slots in #6; Masahiko explained in #7 that notification during replay is too late and proactive feedback would still have propagation races.
- Amit Kapila questioned the slot-invalidation interlock and recovery-time disable requests in #9 and #11; Masahiko explained in #12 that the checkpointer already avoids disabling during recovery and that suppressing requests could lose a disable operation across promotion.
- After Amit approved landing the activation fix independently in #10, the first patch of #4 landed unchanged as 0fd30e2119, and Masahiko reposted the remaining standby fix with clearer comments in #13.
- Amit supplied recovery and slot-state comment improvements in #14 and #15, also reporting a Windows test failure; Masahiko incorporated the comments and background-session cleanup in #16, which Amit approved in #17.
- The standby deactivation fix from #16 landed as 6aba42c660 with only two test-comment edits, while retaining an explicit limitation for logical decoding being disabled and re-enabled during synchronization.
- Buildfarm failures immediately exposed canceled psql sessions exiting before the new quit() calls; Masahiko supplied #19, keeping those sessions alive after cancellation and removing their explicit trailing quit commands, which landed unchanged as 18f9785e0b.
- Tom Lane confirmed that the remaining red buildfarm results predated the cleanup fix in #22, and Masahiko declared the original open item resolved in #23.
- Nikolay Samokhvalov reopened the correctness work in #24 with a reproducer for the documented disable/re-enable hole and a generation-counter patch that rejects stale fetched slot information.
- Masahiko replaced the generation counter with a replayed status-change LSN in #25, arguing that this checks WAL decodability directly and that validation immediately after slot creation avoids unnecessary work and bypasses through early returns.
- Shveta Malik proposed integrating LSN updates into activation and explicitly initializing shared state in #26, while Nisha Moond found repeated slot creation and deletion on lagging standbys in #27.
- Masahiko's #29 tracked only replayed activation records and skipped the new validation when the remote restart LSN was ahead of replay; Nisha verified both the original race and lagging-standby behavior in #30.
- Shveta supplied a comment fix in #31, and Zhijie Hou questioned the replay-position and retry handling in #32; Masahiko explained why an unreplayed but valid remote slot should be retained in #33.
- Masahiko incorporated Shveta's explanations and split out a shared-memory initialization prerequisite in #34, choosing an initialization callback instead of resetting the field at promotion.
- Amit challenged the safety of skipping validation ahead of replay in #35; Nisha confirmed the existing replay wait in #37, and Masahiko explained in #38 that the acquired slot makes later deactivation trigger a recovery conflict, leading Amit to request only clearer comments in #39.
- Nisha supplied TAP refinements in #40; after Shveta noticed that #41 accidentally repeated the previous patches, Masahiko posted the actual comment and test updates in #43, which Shveta approved in #45.
- The two patches in #43 landed separately with matching code diffs as initialization commit 952cb07913 and slotsync correctness commit 1f2245371e, announced in #46.
- Fujii Masao diagnosed a new buildfarm test failure in #47: the replacement synchronized slot could become persistent before cleanup, so invalidation alone did not remove it; he proposed an extra synchronization cycle.
- Masahiko adopted Fujii's simpler cleanup approach in #48, Shveta approved it in #49, and it landed unchanged as d64e535748.
- Alexander Lakhin reported another intermittent failure in #51, reproducing it by delaying injection-point exit cleanup and identifying similar failures in concurrent-upsert and REPACK tests.
- Hayato Kuroda reproduced the failure and proposed waiting for injection-point removal in #52, then expanded the work in #53 with explicit REPACK teardown and backend-exit waits for concurrent-upsert tests.
- Masahiko suggested explicit detachment in #54, but Hayato demonstrated in #55 that a delayed exiting backend could still remove another backend's newly registered point, and changed the recovery test to wait for backend termination.
- Masahiko accepted the revised recovery and REPACK patches while leaving the concurrent-upsert patch for further review in #56; Hayato posted naming and verbosity refinements in #57, leaving this three-patch test-stability series uncommitted at the thread's end and the broader injection-point ownership issue unresolved.