model-writtenrun 6864 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Kevin Rocker opened the thread with #1, removing a GIN pending-list vacuum delay that ran while holding a buffer lock and relying on existing unlocked delay points.
- Neil Chen suggested delaying immediately after the flush-path unlock in #2, and Kevin supplied that optional addition in #3; after Kevin explained the existing per-entry delays, Neil agreed in #4 that the original removal was sufficient, and the extra flush delay was dropped.
- Andrey Borodin's instrumentation found more ineffective interrupt checks, leading to the broader patch in #5: move GIN and ANALYZE delays before lock acquisition, but initially document the unresolved hash lock-chaining and statistics partition-lock cases.
- Neil Chen supplied an experimental hash per-bucket relocation and assertions in #6, warning that long overflow chains could receive less throttling; Andrey questioned permanent assertions and requested broader testing in #7, after which Neil reported successful check-world testing but agreed to defer hash and the assertions in #9.
- Tom Lane revived the idea of asserting that vacuum delays are interruptible in #11, and Kevin incorporated that invariant and Neil's hash relocation into #13, reporting that the hash call failed the assertion before relocation and that the resulting series passed check-world.
- Andrey endorsed the per-bucket placement in #14, citing a production shutdown delay and Mostafa's independently tested equivalent fix as reasons to backpatch, and requested INTERRUPTS_CAN_BE_PROCESSED() so the assertion also checked query-cancel holdoff.
- Kevin adopted the stronger assertion and reported clean full CI in #15; Andrey considered the series ready in #16, recommending backpatching the fixes while considering the assertion separately, and Kevin corrected the remaining commit-message typos in #17.
- After a month, Kevin split ANALYZE into a separate patch in #18 following Greg Burd's report, treating it as a PostgreSQL 19 regression; Andres Freund explained in #19 that sleeping or processing configuration changes while holding these locks had already been unsafe in older releases.
- Heikki Linnakangas committed 96c99955b6, combining the later GIN, hash, ANALYZE and vacuum.c patch in #1156597 from thread #253470 with this thread's statistics-lock finding carried in #18; for the latter, he removed the ineffective interrupt check instead of annotating it.
- The commit explanation in 96c99955b6 leaves out the assertion because untested callers, including extensions, might violate it and instead makes vacuum_delay_point() return when interrupts cannot be processed; Heikki's final message #20 confirms the fixes were committed and backported to all stable branches, completing the thread without the permanent assertion.