model-writtenrun 303 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Bharath Rupireddy reported a reproducible startup hang when the decoding worker never becomes ready in #1, and Nathan Bossart immediately identified a related teardown deadlock in #2.
- Bharath's initial patch in #3 used a latch and worker-status checks during startup and detached the error queue before waiting for shutdown; Antonin Houska's review in #4 led to shorter comments and reuse of the existing background-worker startup wait event in #5.
- Masahiko Sawada questioned how queued worker errors were preserved in #6, while Antonin examined queue attachment and shutdown signaling in #7; Bharath consequently separated attachment checking from decoding initialization in #8, then applied Antonin's helper-signature and comment corrections in #10.
- Nikolay Samokhvalov demonstrated that silent worker exits still stranded initialization, snapshot, and replay waits, supplying a patch atop the existing fixes with status polling and isolation tests in #11.
- Antonin questioned whether direct proc_exit() calls represented a real failure in #12; Nikolay then reproduced a worker termination whose error was lost through a full message queue in #13, establishing a practical route to the hang.
- Bharath's expanded series in #14 retained the startup fixes but replaced post-attachment status polling with an explicit Terminate message and an error on unexpected queue detachment, also adding broader injection-point tests and pending-flag cleanup; Antonin confirmed the detached-queue diagnosis in #15.
- Shihao Zhong tested the series and found that detaching shared memory before worker shutdown could destroy its shared file set during startup, so #16 restored the later detachment and added test timeouts while retaining the termination-message design.
- Álvaro Herrera committed the first two patches from #16 as 47b5b23a78, with changes to startup-loop control flow, termination handling, shutdown state, and protocol naming; this commit contains neither the test patch nor the pending-flag cleanup.
- Álvaro announced the fixes had been pushed in #17 but deferred the tests because their injection-point infrastructure changes needed more consideration, suggesting simpler coverage for PostgreSQL 19 and broader work for PostgreSQL 20.
- Bharath accepted leaving the tests in the thread for reference in #18, citing the work required for reliable, deterministic coverage, and thanked Shihao for finding and fixing the teardown race.