model-writtenrun 8451 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Vik Fearing proposed IMPLIES as a more readable alternative to NOT a OR b, especially in CHECK constraints, and submitted separate documentation and implementation patches in #1; the initial implementation used right associativity and expanded the operator during parse analysis.
- Nathan Bossart argued that preserving IMPLIES when stored expressions are printed would strengthen its readability benefit in #2, while Vik initially considered that extra work unnecessary in #5.
- Thom Brown questioned chaining, NULL behavior, and expression evaluation in #3; Vik explained the intended semantics in #4 and corrected his initial interpretation of the arithmetic example in #6, and solai v subsequently reported successful operator, constraint, NULL, and regression testing in #7.
- Nathan accepted the proposed name, precedence below OR, and inherited evaluation behavior but advocated forbidding implication chains because their meaning was easy to misread in #9; Vik initially defended right associativity and added explanatory documentation and tests in #10.
- Jacob Champion and Isaac Morland supported requiring explicit grouping in #11 and #12, while Zsolt Parragi also supported non-associativity and identified a precedence test that could pass with either grouping in #13 and #15.
- After Nathan renewed the request to investigate round-trip preservation in #16, Vik submitted #17 with non-associative syntax, the corrected precedence test, and a separate implementation that retained IMPLIES in stored expressions and deferred expansion to optimizer simplification.
- Nathan endorsed the truth-table layout but requested retaining NULL terminology in #18; he also requested errors instead of defensive executor and postgres_fdw expansion, fewer implementation tests, documentation of evaluation order, and a catalog-version bump.
- Nathan posted the revised documentation patch alone in #19, preserving the matrix layout while restoring TRUE/FALSE/NULL terminology; Joel Jacobson separately supported non-associativity in #20.
- Nathan committed the documentation from #19 as c074737f68 with an unchanged diff and rewritten commit explanation, announcing it in #21; the IMPLIES implementation and stored-expression support remained for subsequent work.
- Nathan took over revision of the remaining implementation in #22, crediting Vik as author and himself as co-author, and combined operator support and stored-expression preservation into one patch while requesting another round of human and LLM review.
- The revision in #22 constructs BoolExpr directly in the grammar, removes defensive executor and postgres_fdw expansion, handles IMPLIES in nonnullable-variable analysis, and reduces the tests while adding focused view-deparsing coverage; it retains optimizer-time expansion and leaves a catalog-version bump marked as outstanding.
- Following LLM review, Nathan posted #23 with a missing operator-documentation update and IMPLIES flattening in simplify_or_arguments() to avoid simplifying arguments twice.
- Nathan reported in #23 that the new keyword makes a function call such as ROWS BETWEEN implies(1) PRECEDING AND CURRENT ROW a syntax error, but favored leaving this edge case unchanged because attempts to fix it appeared to break other syntax.
- In #24, Nathan confirmed that decision after further investigation and considered the implementation committable, but planned to allow another week or two for feedback; only the truth-table documentation had landed, with the IMPLIES implementation still awaiting commitment.