model-writtenrun 204 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Manu proposed extending an existing REPACK (CONCURRENTLY) isolation test to verify index_rebuild_count, reporting that it caught both previously fixed counting bugs when those fixes were individually reverted #1.
- Alvaro Herrera objected to testing a single progress snapshot through injection points and proposed a systematic tracing framework #2; Manu investigated centralized progress updates and asked about its design #3, after which Alvaro favored compile-time instrumentation, logging only changes, and broad command coverage #4, while Michael Paquier likewise supported checking complete progress sequences #5.
- Manu replaced the isolation-test approach with PROGRESS_DEBUG server logging and a TAP trace checker, accompanied by four fixes for initial heap-scan counts, index-build counter resets, VACUUM dead-item resets, and parallel GIN double counting; he reported successful tests and left configuration, log volume, and writes outside active commands open for discussion #6.
- Manu added a dependent documentation cross-check that compared reported phases with system_views.sql and monitoring.sgml, detecting a REPACK phase-order discrepancy #7, then bundled it with the complete preceding series after CI could not apply the standalone delta #8.
- Manu repaired attachment encoding, expanded command coverage, and taught the checker about data-checksum NULL counters; he also removed documentation-order comparisons following Sami's objection reported from another thread, retaining phase-membership checks and fixing assertions and debug-build detection #9.
- After nearly two weeks, Manu rebased the series and added the newly introduced per-index VACUUM progress parameter to its specification, demonstrating the completeness check's ability to detect new counters #10.
- Michael Paquier accepted the heap-scan and parallel GIN findings and identified another missing GIN tuple-count increment, but objected to resetting index-build counters when progress reporting was disabled and questioned the need for immediate VACUUM dead-item resets #11.
- Shortly after that review, Michael committed the heap-scan and GIN fixes from #10, without their added comments, together with his additional GIN fix in 3be29d9346; the commit credits Manu and Michael and declines backpatching because the reporting errors are cosmetic.
- The supplied thread therefore ends with two proposed fixes landed, the other two questioned, and the tracing framework and documentation checker still uncommitted; the last discussion does not resolve the remaining objections or framework design questions #6 #11 3be29d9346.