model-writtenrun 8489 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Bertrand Drouvot proposed reporting buffer access strategies for executed table and index scans under EXPLAIN ANALYZE with BUFFERS, alongside independently applicable documentation fixes; after discussion with Andres Freund, he deliberately left ring sizes and activity counters out of the initial scope #1.
- Sami Imseih found missing worker-only SampleScan and TidScan reporting, questioned the assumption that index strategies cannot change on rescan, and requested index-only coverage and clearer shared-buffer documentation #2; Bertrand's next submission added the missing worker infrastructure, retained the latest strategy, and split the work into eight patches #3.
- Sami demonstrated that a parameterized TABLESAMPLE scan can switch between bulkread and normal, and that Bloom could report bulkread despite exiting before an index search #4; Bertrand proposed preserving every observed strategy in a bitmask and displaying a list instead of giving ring strategies precedence #5.
- Sami suggested per-strategy buffer counters #6, but Bertrand argued for keeping this series focused on selected strategies with lightweight instrumentation #7, and Sami accepted deferring the counters #8.
- Bertrand implemented strategy lists across rescans, moved index recording to actual search paths, added early-exit tests, and documented that scan reporting excludes write-side strategies such as a CTAS destination's bulkwrite strategy #9.
- Michael Paquier requested clearer documentation of normal replacement, preservation of command examples, removal of redundant vacuum wording, and recognition of checksum operations #10; Bertrand applied those changes while keeping the pg_stat_io corrections separate because he considered them backpatchable #11.
- Lukas Fittl judged overlap with his instrumentation work manageable through rebasing #12, then questioned default output noise and the value of index reporting when Bloom was the only in-tree index user of bulkread, recommending VERBOSE gating and simpler helper names #13.
- Michael requested clearer L2-cache wording, checksum coverage in the glossary, and fewer repeated glossary links #14, and recommended the fuller term Buffer Access Strategy ring outside the glossary #15; Bertrand accepted those documentation directions #16 #17.
- Bertrand agreed to require VERBOSE while retaining explicit normal reporting because absence could also mean an unexecuted scan or unavailable instrumentation; he kept index reporting provisionally and deferred broader worker-instrumentation cleanup #19.
- The next submission implemented VERBOSE gating, helper renaming, and documentation refinements, and reduced Bloom's test burden by moving ordinary index coverage into the shared scan tests, while leaving index reporting available for further review #20.
- Michael expressed readiness to apply the README and glossary changes but requested retaining only the pg_stat_io glossary link and merging it into the glossary patch #22; after Bertrand raised the backpatch rationale again #23, Michael reaffirmed that he did not support most of the additional wording #24.
- Bertrand's final seven-patch submission made that documentation reduction and merge #25; the supplied thread records no landing, and EXPLAIN reporting remains under review with the necessity of index reporting still unresolved.