model-writtenrun 9084 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Konstantin Knizhnik reported an XLC-specific WAL insertion deadlock under concurrent pgbench load in #1, and Bernd Helmle reported similar failures on AIX and Linux with XLC in #3.
- Heikki Linnakangas supplied diagnostic WAL assertions in #4; Konstantin's failures in #5 and #6 showed inconsistent state despite an exclusive lightweight lock and shifted attention to missing memory barriers.
- Konstantin's fix in #9 added explicit synchronization around XLC atomics; Heikki added trailing instruction synchronization and compiler guards in #10, and Konstantin corrected and tested the revised patch in #15.
- Heikki argued that replacing the AIX libc spinlock functions with XLC intrinsics was unrelated and would require compiler guards in #18, and Konstantin agreed to leave those functions alone in #21.
- Tony Reix separately proposed two ways to enable large-file support in #19, but neither proposal appears in the supplied candidate commits.
- After prolonged testing, Konstantin reported near-zero throughput without the original deadlock in #22; Tony's kernel-debugging advice in #23 also led to an exiting-process kernel stack in #26, without a demonstrated fix for that separate symptom.
- Noah Misch recommended replacing fetch-add intrinsics with inline assembly in #27, because adding barriers around the intrinsics would duplicate synchronization on older XLC versions.
- Michael Paquier revived the issue and suggested compiler-version checks in #28, but Andres Freund favored assembly in #35 and Noah explained in #36 that assembly could be verified without access to every XLC version.
- The 2018 revival produced discussion of buildfarm coverage and compiler support rather than a replacement patch, and Michael removed the unsolicited CommitFest entry in #41.
- Noah resumed implementation in #43 with three patches: regression coverage, an XLC-specific assembly fix intended for backpatching, and development-branch unification of PPC fetch-add implementations.
- Tom Lane questioned the effort spent preserving immediate-add instructions in #44, and Noah retained the optimization to avoid worsening generated code relative to GCC intrinsics in #45.
- The three attachments from #43 landed unchanged as regression tests in f380c51901, the XLC fix in dd50f1a432, and initial PPC unification in e7ff59686e.
- The initial unification in e7ff59686e was backed out after older-GCC failures; Noah's replacement in #46 retained the already-landed tests and XLC fix while adding shared assembly compare-exchange implementations and removing generic-xlc.h.
- Tom's Apple compiler rejected an addi operand allocated to r0 in #47, so Noah tightened its constraint in #48 and explained why the atomic API still required full barriers rather than the weaker spinlock barriers.
- After successful check-world testing, Tom requested removal of assembly-construction macros and a matching headerscheck update in #49; Noah incorporated those changes in #50, retained the configure probe because XLC needed it, and attached a separate spinlock constraint fix.
- The thread ends with Tom confirming compilation and regression-test success for the final patch set on older Apple machines in #51.
- The final attachments from #50 subsequently landed unchanged as the backpatched spinlock constraint correction in 89b4d7744c and the revised PPC atomic implementation in 30ee5d17c2, completing the atomic-operation work represented by the candidates.