model-writtenrun 5585 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
Jun - Aug 2017 · 6 entries
- Marina Polyakova opened the thread with a proposal to keep pgbench clients running after serialization and deadlock failures, report those failures, and add an isolation-level option, without initially retrying failed work #1.
- Kevin Grittner, Alvaro Herrera, and Thomas Munro argued for retrying transactions; Kevin explained that dependent statements must be reevaluated and successful completions should determine throughput #5 #6 #7 #12.
- Andres Freund pointed out that PGOPTIONS already controls isolation level, and the dedicated option disappeared despite Alexander Korotkov's usability argument #4 #19 #20.
- Fabien Coelho's review shaped the client state machine, saved randomness, and reporting integration, leading to Marina's first retry-capable implementation #14 #20.
- Further review produced a Variables container, simpler counters, and consolidated tests; savepoint-level retries were deferred, and transactions spanning scripts remained unretried #21 #22 #34 #37.
- Andres's testing and Alexander's feedback encouraged keeping clients alive after ordinary SQL errors while reserving retries for serialization and deadlock failures #38 #39.
Mar - Oct 2018 · 8 entries
- After a long gap, Teodor Sigaev challenged the complexity of recognizing transaction boundaries, and Fabien proposed retrying entire scripts with their client state reset; Marina implemented that model in the next major rewrite #43 #44 #46 #47.
- Teodor's follow-up exposed inconsistent variable restoration, and subsequent revisions restored variables on final failure and added bounded retry time #48 #50 #51.
- Ildus Kurbangaliev tested the feature and requested logging cleanups; Marina incorporated those changes and reused --latency-limit instead of retaining a separate retry-time option #52 #53.
- Alvaro requested splitting the oversized patch, producing separate RandomState, Variables, logging, and retry components #55 #58.
- Fabien's tests and Alvaro's allocation review led to independent random streams for thread activities, revised variable allocation, and faster PL/pgSQL-based failure tests in the existing TAP suite #59 #60 #75 #81.
- Fabien rejected blocking rollback in the asynchronous client state machine, while he and Arthur Zakirov challenged logging complexity; Marina introduced asynchronous rollback and moved the logging refactor to an optional final patch #95 #84 #88 #101.
- Fabien insisted that unrelated SQL and meta-command errors retain their existing abort and diagnostic behavior, and Marina accepted that narrower scope #103 #109 #110.
- Alvaro committed only the RandomState preparation from #101, with member renaming and stylistic edits, as 4092319194; the retry work remained outstanding #112.
May - Jul 2021 · 5 entries
- After the long stall, Yugo Nagata revived Marina's work, retaining the Variables and retry patches while dropping the committed RandomState component and the logging patch superseded by common APIs; he also implemented the narrower error policy and corrected reporting #121 #122.
- Fabien and Tatsuo Ishii reviewed defaults, counters, option names, and timeout behavior, leading to explicit retry enablement, --verbose-errors, and clearer documentation of recoverable failures #129 #133 #140 #142.
- Yugo then corrected pipeline rollback handling and stopped starting retries after the benchmark timer expired #147.
- Following another extended pause, Yugo incorporated Fabien's review by removing unnecessary retry-state snapshots, improving pipeline cleanup and transaction-status handling, and making reporting more consistent #148 #149.
- At the thread's end, the retry feature and follow-up fixes had landed, while superseded documentation proposals and the separate logging refactor were no longer pending; aggregate-format tests remained future work promised by Fabien, and Tom had separately proposed revisiting unaggregated logging #122 #196 #203.
Feb - Apr 2022 · 8 entries
- Fabien's final substantive review prompted helper extraction, buffer reuse, and reporting fixes; Tatsuo reviewed the resulting code and documentation, then committed both remaining patches from #160 unchanged as 4a39f87acd #152 #153 #161 #162.
- Tom Lane reported a buildfarm failure caused by a broken retry-test regular expression; Yugo restored the missing capture expression in #164, which landed unchanged as ac9c5dc5d4 #163.
- The first test fix still failed on old Perl because its backreference syntax was unsupported; Tom identified the problem and a missed second occurrence, then Tom and Yugo verified Tatsuo's corrected #169, committed unchanged as 0f79caa3c6 #166 #168 #170 #171.
- Tom also reported PDF overflow in the expanded log synopsis; Tatsuo's line-folding proposal and Yugo's zero-width-space revisions did not adequately address both HTML and PDF presentation #174 #175 #176 #178 #179.
- Alvaro requested clearer aggregate-log explanations, and Tom showed that optional columns made the format intrinsically ambiguous; Alvaro's proposal to always emit fixed columns with zero values when unused gained agreement #181 #182 #189 #191.
- Tatsuo implemented fixed aggregate columns, adopted Fabien's requested ordering, and committed #194 unchanged as 17a856d08b #192 #193 #195.
- PDF overflow persisted, so Tom replaced both log-format synopses with field lists in #196; after Tatsuo and Fabien reviewed it, small wording and example-line changes landed as b6b8824ee7 #197 #198 #199.
- Tom also observed that the aggregate failures total merely duplicated the serialization and deadlock counts; Tatsuo removed it in #200, Fabien validated the patch, and it landed unchanged as a62bff74b1 #196 #201 #202.