model-writtenrun 9139 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
Jul - Oct 2017 · 4 entries
- Craig Ringer proposed a pageinspect decoder for heap tuple infomasks to simplify corruption and visibility debugging, returning text arrays with optional combined flags while ignoring the attribute-count bits in infomask2 #1.
- Ashutosh Sharma tested the first patch and found crashes, missing frozen output, and inconsistent documentation names; Craig corrected array construction and expanded regression coverage in the next submission #6 #8.
- Moon Insung questioned output that simultaneously showed frozen, committed, and invalid states, and Robert Haas argued for displaying the meaning of combined bits; Tomas Vondra favored retaining raw information for corruption investigations #9 #11 #12.
- Craig proposed raw flags by default with an optional mode that substitutes combined names, while Peter Geoghegan continued to favor literal bit reporting and Robert defended interpreting valid combined states #19 #23 #24 #25.
Aug - Sep 2019 · 13 entries
- After almost two years, Alvaro Herrera revived the work and Masahiko Sawada took over, replacing table-driven decoding with explicit flag checks, implementing the optional combined interpretation, and adding a separate documentation reorganization #32 #33 #35.
- Michael Paquier requested an fsm_page_contents example for the documentation patch, which Sawada added; Michael then committed the revised documentation with the example output removed and prose rearranged, backpatching through PostgreSQL 10 #36 #37 #38 292ae8af79.
- Alvaro's resend exposed a Windows linking failure involving pg_popcount32, and Sawada switched to pg_popcount following Michael's diagnosis #40 #41 #42 #43.
- Amit Kapila, Alvaro, and Michael reviewed naming, access restrictions, memory cleanup, and examples; Sawada adopted heap_tuple_infomask_flags, retained superuser-only access, freed the temporary array, and made the tests easier to read #44 #45 #46 #47 #49 #51 #52.
- Sawada also proposed renaming tuple_data_split, but Alvaro opposed changing a long-established interface and Sawada accepted leaving the existing name alone #52 #53 #54.
- Amit's final review questioned the use of HEAP_XMAX_IS_LOCKED_ONLY for raw output, the treatment of HEAP_LOCKED_UPGRADED as a combined flag, and the decode_combined parameter name #55.
- Michael committed the decoder component with expanded combined-flag tests, clearer documentation, formatting, and an assertion, leaving the separate rename out and the newly raised semantic concerns for follow-up #56 #57 ddbd5d8731.
- Further discussion established that HEAP_LOCKED_UPGRADED depends on additional conditions and HEAP_XMAX_IS_LOCKED_ONLY does not simply expose a raw bit, so Michael posted a corrective delta removing those interpretations and improving flag ordering #60 #62 #63.
- Alvaro proposed returning raw and combined flags in separate columns, and Amit supported that interface; proposals to separate infomask from infomask2 were considered unnecessary #64 #65 #71 #72.
- Michael implemented the two-column interface, incorporated the earlier flag corrections, and changed combined-mask tests to require every constituent bit; Alvaro's review then improved tuple construction, comments, and documentation #73 #74 #75.
- Amit identified that the function should return one record rather than SETOF record and suggested reusing the flags allocation; Michael incorporated both changes into the final attachment #76 #78.
- Michael committed the redesign from the final attachment with only comment, documentation, and regression-query cleanup, and Amit subsequently checked the committed result #79 #80 58b4cb30a5.
- The thread ended with the documentation and redesigned decoder landed, the existing tuple_data_split name retained, and Craig thanking the contributors for improving corruption debugging #53 #79 #82.