model-writtenrun 9683 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Andres Freund proposed extensible TupleTableSlots with specialized structures and callbacks in #1, aiming to support pluggable storage and future vectorized execution while making tuple-format conversions explicit.
- Alexander Korotkov questioned the prototype's fixed slot-type enumeration and discussed system-column projection and avoiding unnecessary format conversions in #2; Andres subsequently ruled out completing the work for PostgreSQL 11 in #4.
- Ashutosh Bapat advanced the prototype through archived revisions described in #5 and #6, restoring tts_ field names, fixing regression failures, and separating native-format materialization from fetching tuples whose memory the caller must release.
- The narrowed attribute count exposed LLVM crashes, prompting Ashutosh's incomplete fix in #6 and the later resolution reported in #15.
- Ashutosh introduced additional attribute-access callbacks in #8, but Andres argued in #9 and #11 that separate getattr and null-check callbacks complicated the API without sufficient benefit.
- Andres supplied slot-type and JIT corrections in #17, including initializing the system-variable slot argument; Ashutosh incorporated them and reported successful check-world testing in #18, then corrected the additional ScanState assumption in #20.
- The first candidate cleanup landed as 88ebd62fcc, extracting Ashutosh's slot_getallattrs() deduplication from the archived series into an independently useful change.
- Andres's extensive review in #21 requested smaller independently reviewable patches, corrected buffer ownership, and challenged redundant callbacks; Ashutosh addressed several points in #22, and Alvaro Herrera caught an inverted shouldFree comment in #23.
- Amit Khandekar took over posting revisions in #26, incorporating Ashutosh's separated materialization changes and implementing a getsysattr callback that errors for unsupported slot types following Andres's preference in #25.
- Andres announced four preparatory landings in #27: the revised attribute-width fix from #6 became a598708ffa, while archived patches became the extended prologue cleanup bbdfbb9154, polished store-function split 29c94e03c7, and obsolete-function removal 10763358c3.
- Andres required every intermediate commit to compile and proposed introducing empty slot-operation structures before the main abstraction in #29; Amit reorganized the archived series accordingly in #32.
- Kyotaro Horiguchi discussed open-coded flag setters and bitfields in #30, while Tom Lane questioned the performance benefit in #31; Andres reported measured improvements from fewer loads, cheaper clearing, and improved cache behavior in #36.
- Amit diagnosed dangling references during partitioned INSERT ON CONFLICT processing and changed tuple copying to precede descriptor replacement in #34, which also removed the disputed null-check optimization.
- The archived function-movement preparation landed as 9d906f1119, followed by flag consolidation in c5257345ef, combining the original packing idea with the LLVM flag updates visible in #17.
- Amit isolated a JIT hash-join failure caused by confusing actual input-slot types with result-slot types in #39; 5f32b29c18 subsequently corrected the parent used to initialize HashState hash-key expressions.
- Andres's heavily revised series in #41 made PlanState expose slot-type information, computed expression-fetch metadata during initialization, and added assertions to validate those assumptions, avoiding JIT deforming for virtual slots.
- The same revision #41 unified heap-tuple fetching under an explicit shouldFree contract, enabled virtual-slot materialization, centralized missing-column handling, and removed redundant callbacks; Andres reported neutral or slightly improved benchmark performance.
- Andres announced that the remaining polishing and abstraction work had been completed and pushed in #42, and Amit moved the trigger-slot follow-up to a separate discussion in #43.
- Jeff Janes reported a CTAS memory leak from the landed materialization changes and supplied a tested heap_freetuple() fix in #44; Michael Paquier committed it unchanged as 414a9d3cf3 and confirmed reproducing the leak in #45.
- The thread ended with the abstraction and immediate leak fix landed, but Andres still questioned whether CTAS and materialized-view receivers needed short-lived memory contexts in #46, while discussion of copied tuples and downstream receiver code remained unresolved through #50.