model-writtenrun 9583 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Masahiko Sawada proposed copying logical replication slots with optional output-plugin and persistence changes so users could inspect conflicting replicated data from the same WAL position in #1.
- Michael Paquier requested proper source-slot acquisition in #2, which Sawada implemented in #3, and explained how physical-slot copies could support multiple standbys initialized from one base backup in #4; Peter Eisentraut identified the analogous logical-replica use case in #5, and physical-slot support arrived in #7.
- Paquier's review in #8 called for broader, faster test_decoding coverage and questioned releasing the source before copying; his follow-up #11 identified the risk that checkpoints could remove required WAL.
- Sawada addressed that concurrency problem in #16 by retaining the source slot, temporarily switching MyReplicationSlot during destination creation, and installing error cleanup for both slots, while moving and expanding the regression tests.
- After refreshing the patch in #17, Sawada incorporated Paquier's review #18 into #22, rejecting physical slots without reserved WAL, simplifying error cleanup, and restructuring tests; optional persistence changes remained useful for temporary investigative copies as explained in #21.
- Petr Jelinek found that releasing a slot cleared MyReplicationSlot before the cleanup callback's comparison in #23, prompting the fix in #24; his further requests for clearer WAL-failure comments and consistent errors in #25 were incorporated in #26, which he subsequently marked ready for committer in #27.
- Andres Freund challenged the source-slot ownership workaround and the changes to WAL reservation in #28, proposing two successive copies of source state; Sawada and Freund clarified source-drop detection in #29 and #30.
- Sawada implemented that redesign in #31, consolidating logical and physical copying into one helper, permitting copying without acquiring the source slot, validating its identity and restart LSN on the second read, and moving the plugin argument after the common temporary argument.
- Paquier questioned the revised concurrency window in #32, and Sawada explained the destination's protection in #33; subsequent patches #34 and #35 removed redundant checks and variables and clarified comments.
- The final submission #37 resolved catalog OID collisions with jsonpath functions while retaining the revised copying algorithm.
- Alvaro Herrera committed #37 as 9f06d79ef8, making light comment, diagnostic, wrapper-name, formatting, and catalog edits, and announced the landing in #38.
- Jelinek spotted a remaining comment typo in #39, Sawada agreed in #40, and Herrera reported fixing it in #41, leaving the feature landed with no outstanding patch series in this thread.