model-writtenrun 9572 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- The thread began with Michael Paquier's announcement of expanded autovacuum logging in #1, after which Álvaro Herrera questioned whether an anti-wraparound vacuum could ever be non-aggressive in #2.
- Robert Haas questioned the distinction in #4, while Sergei Kornilov and Andres Freund explained that aggressive scanning and protection from cancellation have different purposes and thresholds in #5 and #6.
- Jim Nasby proposed removing is_wraparound and moving wraparound protection into lazy_vacuum_rel() in #7, but Andres objected that this pushed generic behavior into code becoming heap-specific in #8; that refactoring was not carried forward.
- Sergei demonstrated three logging combinations in #10, and Álvaro maintained that only the non-aggressive anti-wraparound combination was impossible in #11, leading Masahiko Sawada to submit a small assertion and logging cleanup in #12.
- Michael requested an assertion independent of logging settings in #13, and Tom Lane recommended folding its condition into Assert in #16; Masahiko and Michael refined its placement, expression, and comments through #17 and #19.
- Michael's concurrent pgbench and regression testing triggered the supposedly impossible assertion in #21, preventing the assertion-only cleanup from being committed.
- Kyotaro Horiguchi attributed the failure to differing snapshot and relcache views of relfrozenxid and proposed skipping the already-vacuumed relation in #22, replacing the assertion-based approach with an early return.
- After several months, Andrew Dunstan revived the patch and requested removal of the now-unreachable logging branch in #23; Michael incorporated that cleanup, updated the patch for the relocated heap code, and expanded its explanation in #25.
- Andrew supplied clearer diagnostic and comment wording in #26, while Álvaro recommended DEBUG1 because skipping redundant work should not produce a normal log entry in #28; Andrew supported that choice in #30, and Michael accepted it in #31.
- Michael committed 2aa6e331ea from #25, incorporating the wording and logging-level feedback plus a previously missing pgstat_progress_end_command() call, which he explained in #32.
- Nearly a year later, Andres challenged the concurrency explanation and warned that the skip could conceal underlying bugs in #33; Michael agreed in #34 and proposed reverting it so table_recheck_autovac() remained responsible for skipping work, leaving the thread with a landed change under reconsideration and no demonstrated revert.