model-writtenrun 9597 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Chen Huajun reported production GIN deadlocks affecting inserts, autovacuum, and standby recovery in #1, then traced the primary deadlock to conflicting parent-child lock acquisition in #2.
- Peter Geoghegan identified the subtree-locking design as incompatible with insertion lock ordering in #5, while Chen separately demonstrated the standby replay deadlock and proposed left-sibling-first locking in #9.
- Andrey Borodin recognized that concurrent internal-page splits invalidate the assumption that inserters pin every ancestor in #12, then proposed rightlink-based concurrent leaf deletion and delayed page reuse in #13.
- Peter argued that the broad redesign was unsuitable for stable branches and should be considered as a future feature in #14; Alexander Korotkov subsequently proposed restoring root locking while retaining the optimization of locking only when empty pages exist in #17.
- Andrey supplied a conservative root-locking patch and identified missed pages during concurrent splits in #19; Alexander replaced its recursive traversal with a rightlink leaf scan and separate deletion pass in #21.
- Andrey reviewed the new leaf access code in #22, and Alexander preserved that implementation while refining its explanation in #27; it landed unchanged as fd83c83d09.
- Alexander also identified a page-reuse hazard introduced by searches that skip through posting trees in #21, and requested a separate extraction of Andrey's transaction-ID mechanism in #23, leaving the broader concurrent-deletion redesign for future development.
- Andrey extracted the page-reuse fix in #25; Alexander chose the existing pd_prune_xid field for binary compatibility and found missing initialization in #26, then requested complete WAL initialization and B-tree-style horizon and FSM checks in #29.
- The corrected page-reuse patch in #31 became 52ac6cd2d0, with equivalent checks consolidated into a shared macro, header organization cleaned up, and README documentation updated.
- Alexander supplied the independent standby lock-order fix in #30, which landed unchanged as c6ade7a8cd; he announced all three December fixes in #32.
- Bruce Momjian and Tom Lane reported an uninitialized-buffer warning in the PostgreSQL 9.4 backpatch in #34 and #35, and Andrey identified a duplicate release in #36; Alexander corrected initialization and buffer lock lifetimes in bf0e5a73be, announced in #37.
- The post-commit discussion left unlock order unchanged because it was unnecessary for the deadlock fix, although Andres Freund explained a possible scheduling advantage of reverse-order unlocking in #38; Bruce confirmed the compiler warning was gone in #40.
- In March, Simon Riggs reported that the added deleteXid field broke replay of WAL generated by unpatched servers in #41, prompting Alexander's record-length-based compatibility fix in #42.
- Simon requested validation of both supported record lengths in #43, and Alvaro Herrera requested an explanation in #44; Alexander added assertions, an old-format structure, and comments in #45.
- The compatibility revision landed unchanged as 89f39736f4, with the final push confirmed in #47; the targeted fixes and follow-up repairs were complete, while the original broader concurrent-deletion redesign had not landed in this thread.