model-writtenrun 9726 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Andres Freund proposed delaying initialization of bulk-extended pages to avoid unnecessary writes and heap-specific assumptions that complicated pluggable storage, while removing misleading vacuum warnings about legitimate zero pages #1.
- Amit Kapila supported recording uninitialized pages in the FSM, Robert Haas explained that avoiding vacuum warnings had motivated the existing initialization, and Tom Lane argued that crash recovery made those warnings unnecessarily alarming #2 #3 #6.
- Andres posted a prototype that initialized pages when selected for insertion and let vacuum register zero pages in the FSM; it deliberately avoided marking those pages all-visible and all-frozen so a promoted standby could rediscover their free space #8.
- Tom reviewed the prototype, requesting corrected comments and simpler FSM logic and questioning the DEBUG message; Andres incorporated those changes, removed logging, and additionally stopped forcing vacuum processing of new pages when a cleanup lock was unavailable #10 #11.
- The first implementation landed as e6799d5a53, derived from #8, but buildfarm failures immediately showed that another backend could use a newly extended page before the extending backend checked that it was empty #12.
- Andres proposed restoring vacuum's extension-lock interlock and page recheck, then committed that temporary repair as fc02e6724f without an attached patchset #13 #15.
- The repair failed to eliminate the errors, so Andres reverted both the initial implementation and its repair, then reproduced the failure on a FreeBSD machine supplied by Thomas Munro; Tom also identified a matching failure outside the BSD systems #16 #17 #18.
- After discussing the problem with Robert, Andres identified the insertion fallback that probes a relation's last page without consulting the FSM, allowing it to initialize a page before the extending backend locked it; disabling that fallback eliminated failures across 31 FreeBSD test runs #19 #21.
- Andres proposed closing the extension-to-lock window with RBM_ZERO_AND_LOCK and posted a replacement patch that also handled lock ordering and retries when an update needed another buffer #20 #22.
- The replacement landed as 0d1fe9f74e from #22 with light comment and commit-message edits, and Andres reported that the buildfarm was responding better #23.
- At the end of the thread the revised implementation was committed, with no further patch pending; Amit and Thomas attributed the remaining reported failures to unrelated machine and OpenSSL issues, while the unusually high incidence of the original race on BSD remained unexplained #21 #23 #24 #25.