model-writtenrun 9668 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Peter Eisentraut proposed a shared frontend logging API with automatic program prefixes, newline handling, severity filtering, lazy argument evaluation, and optional colors in #1, explicitly separating message printing from program flow control and leaving full pg_ctl and pg_upgrade conversion outside the initial work.
- Tom Lane and Andres Freund advocated compatibility with backend elog/ereport interfaces in #2 and #4, while Alvaro Herrera asked that the API accommodate ongoing pgbench logging work in #5.
- Peter defended a compact frontend API and rejected coupling logging to exception-style control flow in #7; Tom clarified his proposed exit-based wrapper in #10, and Andres suggested a non-exiting error level in #13, but these alternatives were not adopted.
- Donald Dong reported an initdb crash during testing in #14; Peter supplied a conflict-resolved rebase in #15, after which Donald reported successful testing and questioned remaining unfiltered explanatory messages in #16.
- Peter completed additional pg_dump logging conversions, centralized Windows stderr buffering, and added configurable colors and documentation in #17.
- Arthur Zakirov tested the revised patch and its colors in #18, identifying psql output that duplicated the frontend and server severity labels.
- Peter committed #17 as cc8d415117 with further psql severity and terse-output adjustments, pg_rewind progress handling changes, gettext corrections, build integration, and test updates.
- After the commit, Andres objected to the separate frontend interface in #19 and #21, and Michael Paquier criticized remaining FRONTEND conditionals in shared code in #22; Peter defended frontend consolidation as useful independently of a future backend unification project in #23 and #24.
- Alvaro proposed a non-formatting logging variant to avoid translating bare format strings in #25, but Tom questioned mixing formatting and translation semantics in #26, and Alvaro withdrew the proposal in #27, leaving the logging change committed and broader API unification unresolved.