model-writtenrun 9573 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- David Steele proposed documenting why exclusive backups were deprecated, including restart failures, corruption from removing backup_label during restoration, and abandoned backup sessions, in #1.
- Laurenz Albe corrected the claim that a leftover backup_label always prevents startup in #2, and David incorporated that correction while adding stronger recovery error hints in #3.
- Martín Marqués suggested combining related paragraphs in #6, while Peter Eisentraut requested consistent indentation and a different presentation in #7; Magnus Hagander proposed keeping a short warning first and moving the detailed risks later in #9, which David implemented in #11.
- Michael Paquier objected to prescribing postgresql.auto.conf for recovery settings in #12, and Magnus Hagander explained the manual-editing problem in #13; David adopted generic recovery-option wording in #22.
- Peter Eisentraut questioned the negative framing and repeated documentation in #14, suggesting a role for exclusive backups in manual or simple scripted use; Stephen Frost, David Steele, and Magnus Hagander disputed that framing in #16, #21, and #24, leaving eventual feature removal unresolved.
- Robert Haas endorsed the stronger error hints but proposed replacing the separate risk catalogue with warnings embedded in the existing instructions and removing advice to time out pg_stop_backup in #25; David accepted the approach in #26 and incorporated Robert's wording with minor edits in #27.
- Robert Haas committed #27 unchanged as c900c15269 and announced completion in #29, landing both the documentation rewrite and stronger startup error hints.
- After the commit, Magnus Hagander requested consistent use of primary versus master in #30, Peter Eisentraut approved the revised documentation in #31, and David Steele agreed with the terminology correction and requested backpatching in #33.
- The thread ended with the main patch committed but terminology cleanup and backpatching unresolved: Robert Haas preferred considering documentation separately from error messages in #34, Magnus Hagander raised translation concerns in #36, and Peter Eisentraut noted that older branches would need different wording because the hints mention recovery.signal in #37.