model-writtenrun 7706 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Tom Lane opened the thread by identifying missing executable checks, the risk of allowing mismatched minor versions, and an opportunity to default --new-bindir to pg_upgrade's own directory #1.
- Bruce Momjian supported the checks and questioned whether --new-bindir should remain, while Daniel Gustafsson argued for retaining it for testing #2 #3 #4; Peter Eisentraut raised packaging concerns about exact version requirements but supported providing the directory default #5 #7.
- Daniel Gustafsson submitted three patches implementing numeric version matching, additional executable checks, and a CWD default #9; Christoph Berg explained why the executable's directory was the appropriate default, and Daniel adopted that correction #10 #11.
- Peter Eisentraut's review added the missing pg_controldata check and clarified why dump tools must belong to the target version, which Daniel incorporated while alphabetizing the executable list #12 #13.
- Peter Eisentraut also objected to moving executable discovery into option parsing merely to print a default, because discovery failures could prevent --help from working #12 #14; Daniel moved discovery back into setup(), allowed a temporarily missing directory option, exercised the default in the shell test, and added a file-header typo fix #15.
- Peter Eisentraut committed the executable-validation component of #15 unchanged as 0befb4f313 and the directory-default component with help, comment, variable-scope, and Windows-test refinements as 959f6d6a18; he also reported committing the separate typo fix #16.
- The numeric version-check component remained uncommitted because it compared only pg_ctl's version with pg_upgrade's, leaving other binaries unchecked; Peter Eisentraut proposed checking each executable and sharing validation code, and Daniel agreed to rework it #16 #17.
- After a long delay, Daniel returned with a rewritten remaining patch that exported validate_exec() from common code and checked individual executable version strings through a local helper #21.
- Peter Eisentraut requested clearer wording, a helper name reflecting checking rather than finding, and removal of redundant executable-suffix handling; Daniel incorporated these changes in the final submission #22 #23.
- Peter Eisentraut committed that final submission as f06b1c5982, adding newline stripping and clearer version-mismatch diagnostics #24; Daniel acknowledged the improvements, leaving no submitted component awaiting action at the thread's end #25.