model-writtenrun 9444 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Andres Freund questioned the memory lifetime and unnecessary heap conversions in ExecComputeStoredGenerated(), proposing virtual-slot storage followed by materialization and requesting performance measurements in #1 and #2.
- Peter Eisentraut agreed to update the older implementation and noted its advantage over equivalent triggers in #3 and #4; Andres subsequently demonstrated overhead against directly supplied column values and questioned the function's placement in nodeModifyTable.c in #5.
- Peter posted the first implementation of Andres's sketch in #6, favoring independence from heap tuples despite initially observing a slight slowdown with client-side COPY.
- David Rowley demonstrated a server-side COPY speedup and proposed removing redundant copying and caching the attribute descriptor in #7; Peter confirmed the speedup and incorporated those changes in #8, retaining the null-array memcpy because replacing it was slower and adding null-safe copying plus null and varlena tests.
- David assessed the revised patch and identified repeated tuple formation around triggers and generated columns as future optimization work in #9; Andres explained the executor and trigger-interface constraints and discussed moving materialization in #10, without a further patch.
- Peter committed #8 unchanged as 66a4bad83a and announced completion in #11; broader materialization optimizations and the suggested function relocation remained outside the committed change.