model-writtenrun 9459 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Laurenz Albe reported that converting a serial column to identity after dropping its default leaves two owned sequences and breaks inserts, and proposed preventing multiple ownership in #1.
- Laurenz then proposed distinguishing identity sequences by their INTERNAL dependency in #2 and supplied an alternative filtering patch in #3.
- Michael Paquier recommended removing sequence ownership when dropping the default and requested tests in #4; Laurenz implemented that behavior while retaining the original ownership restrictions in #5.
- Alvaro Herrera proposed reusing an existing sequence in #8, but Michael objected that its current value and bounds could be inappropriate in #9; Peter Eisentraut instead supplied a dedicated identity-sequence lookup implementation in #10, rejecting additional special behavior for serial columns.
- Peter suggested a dependency between the sequence and default in #12, Laurenz warned that retrofitting it would prevent backpatching in #13, and Michael continued advocating removal of the existing ownership dependency in #14.
- Laurenz kept dependency removal as a separate desired improvement but moved the identity lookup fix forward by adding a regression test to Peter's implementation in #15.
- Peter committed #15 as 19781729f7 with API cleanup, explanatory comments, and test naming changes, then announced the commit and closed the commitfest item in #16; automatic ownership removal was left out.
- Laurenz pointed out that an ownership-removal patch had already been posted while accepting closure in #17, then requested backpatching in #18; Peter declined in #19 because the problematic operation could be avoided, leaving the fix on the development branch.