model-writtenrun 9140 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
Apr - May 2019 · 2 entries
- Fabien COELHO proposed sharing frontend and backend 64-bit string-conversion functions to remove duplication and improve platform consistency, then supplied the initial patch moving them into src/common/string.c #1 #2.
- After a rebase, Thomas Munro identified a missing declaration in pg_stat_statements; Fabien added the required include and reported that make check-world passed #3 #5 #6.
Jul - Oct 2019 · 16 entries
- Thomas questioned the incompatible signed and unsigned interfaces, prompting Fabien to rename the signed function pg_scanint8 while initially preserving its error-reporting behavior #7 #8.
- Michael Paquier requested consistent naming and consolidation across integer widths, and Thomas handed over the committer role; Robert Haas and Tom Lane supported retaining a PostgreSQL-specific prefix for exposed functions #11 #12 #14 #15.
- Andres Freund proposed status-returning conversion functions with separate error-reporting wrappers, consistent decimal-only unsigned parsing, and dedicated overflow helpers, while opposing a runtime width-dispatching parser because of performance costs #16 #17 #22 #25.
- The patch was returned with feedback at the end of the July commitfest, and discussion subsequently clarified that the unsigned libc-style interface should also be replaced by the common status-returning design #36 #39 #40 #41.
- Fabien resumed the work in August with rewritten signed and unsigned 64-bit parsers, then standardized status names and added unsigned overflow helpers after Michael's review #46 #47 #48 #50.
- Michael split the overflow helpers into a standalone patch, expanded them to unsigned 16-bit and 32-bit operations, and supplied an experimental testing extension; Fabien's feedback led to wider-intermediate multiplication checks instead of division for those smaller types #51 #52 #55.
- Fabien and Michael compared fallback performance and agreed to drop uint128 addition and subtraction paths while retaining uint128 multiplication; Michael committed the revised standalone patch from #55 as 7dedfd22b7 and announced the landing in #59, following the discussion in #56 and #57.
- The overflow testing extension stayed outside core because Michael was unconvinced its ongoing testing cost was justified, and he placed it in his plugin repository instead #58 #59.
- Fabien resent the uncommitted conversion remainder and removed redundant wrappers after review, changing pgbench so an overflowing integer string could fall through to double conversion #60 #61 #63.
- Michael took over the broader refactor, added all six signed and unsigned conversion variants, and measured a substantial unsigned-parsing improvement but a slowdown from his generic size-dispatching backend wrapper #66.
- Andres opposed the generic wrapper and renewed errorOK proposal, advocating typed wrappers and a shared error-reporting function; Michael implemented that design while preserving SQL-specific type names in input errors #67 #69 #71.
- Further review added unsigned checked wrappers, checked completion-tag parsing, and inline wrappers in builtins.h; Fabien's testing and code review then moved the infrequently used error reporter out of line and corrected redundant tests and branch hints #73 #74 #75 #76.
- Broader node-reader conversions exposed type-width warnings and parsing failures, which Michael initially deferred; Andres insisted the failures be understood before applying the refactor #74 #77.
- Michael traced the failures to node tokens containing trailing text that libc parsers accept but the new strict parsers reject, including queryId under additional node-copy testing; the final patch retained a permissive local wrapper in readfuncs.c and simplified repeated comments #79 #81.
- Ashutosh Sharma reviewed the final patch's fixed decimal base, a mismatched function-name comment, and refint's additional validation; Andres and Michael explained the performance rationale and why refint still needed to reject nonpositive values #82 #83 #85.
- By the final message, only the overflow helpers had landed, while the conversion refactor was returned with feedback for lack of interest; Michael recommended a fresh thread for any renewed submission, with broader node-reader changes, strtoint removal, and T_Float handling still deferred #71 #86.