model-writtenrun 8797 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Melanie Plageman and Ashwin Agrawal discovered that the existing regression and isolation tests did not reliably exercise speculative insertion aborts, and Melanie asked how to force that interleaving in #1.
- Andres Freund proposed expression indexes that acquire advisory locks in #2; after Melanie's experiment blocked too early in #3, he outlined separate locks for the initial index probe and speculative insertion in #8.
- Peter Geoghegan pointed to existing stress tests in #4, while Andres preferred deterministic coverage in #5; Thomas Munro proposed controllable C wait points in #6, and Melanie described Greenplum's fault-injection framework in #7, but the submitted implementation used advisory locks.
- Andres posted the three-permutation abort test in #9 and landed it as 08e2edc076, removing temporary executor instrumentation, adding session setup and schedule registration, and announcing the push in #10.
- After that landing, Melanie identified confusing comments and missing speculative-wait coverage in #11, supplied comment changes in #13, and learned from Andres in #12 that isolationtester waits for commands to finish or block before advancing.
- Andres explained how a second non-unique expression index could pause insertion before speculative completion in #14, and Ashwin implemented that additional test in #15.
- Melanie supplied comment improvements in #16 and consolidated them with Ashwin's test in #18, including the index-OID ordering check Andres suggested in #17.
- Melanie expanded the submission to two patches in #21, adding deterministic TOAST-conflict coverage that reused the existing advisory-lock machinery.
- Andres planned a development-branch-only landing after PostgreSQL 12 branched, but identified misleading helper names, an ineffective lock query, and unstable lock identifiers in #22.
- Melanie and Taylor Vesely paired on the revision in #23, fixing the query, removing unstable identifiers, improving diagnostic wording, and replacing the old standalone TOAST test; their broader step-renaming experiment was abandoned because it hindered reuse, while clearer helper-function names appeared in #24.
- When review resumed, Andres raised database filtering and parallel-test concerns in #26, then reproduced an intermittent extra conflict-check iteration and supplied explicit transaction boundaries in #27 so the speculative wait would always be followed by a transaction wait.
- Andres landed the combined work as 43e0841970, incorporating #24 and #27 with database-filtered lock inspection, session identification, and additional lock-state checks; he reported approximately 150 successful local runs in #28.
- The thread ended with the work complete: Amit Kapila asked to mark the Commitfest entry committed in #30, and Andres confirmed that update in #31.