model-writtenrun 9453 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Julien Rouhaud reported that failed table or index reindexing produced an additional misleading database error and supplied a two-clause fix in #1; Michael Paquier confirmed the need to backpatch in #2, Daniel Gustafsson endorsed it in #3, and Álvaro Herrera traced the bug back fourteen years in #4.
- Tom Lane accepted the fix but proposed replacing string-based type dispatch with an enum and switches in #5; Julien explained the existing SQL-construction convenience in #6, and Álvaro advocated converting the enum to text only when generating SQL in #7.
- Julien implemented the enum approach in #8; Michael requested REINDEX_ prefixes and removal of switch defaults in #9, while Tom proposed combining SQL construction into a single switch in #10.
- Michael committed the original patch from #1 unchanged as e51bad8fb4 and backpatched it through PostgreSQL 9.4, then requested a revised refactoring that also folded system-catalog handling into the common function in #11.
- Julien submitted the remaining enum refactoring with the requested changes and a separate system-catalog consolidation patch in #12, keeping the latter separable because of the feature freeze and mentioning a possible future options structure.
- Michael gave the refactoring a preliminary review but recommended waiting until the PostgreSQL 12 branch existed and moving the work to a new thread and CommitFest entry in #13; Julien reported passing TAP tests and agreed to defer it in #14, and Álvaro opposed applying it in PostgreSQL 12 in #15, leaving the bug fixed and the refactoring uncommitted in this thread.