model-writtenrun 8906 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Robert Haas opened the thread with four patches to let table AMs control TOAST-table creation, separate heap-specific code, reuse toasting helpers, and implement TOAST tables with other AMs; the initial implementation used slots and shared chunk-processing logic #1.
- The TOAST-table necessity callback landed through discussion elsewhere, leaving three patches in this thread, with TOAST-AM selection corrected in the remaining series #2.
- Prabhat Sahu tested storage modes, updates, replication, and upgrades against the rebased series, while Thomas Munro found an unused-variable compiler error; Robert fixed that error, updated formatting, and added generic detoasting-function renames #4 #5 #7.
- Robert's further measurements found no reproducible performance regression, but Andres Freund's review raised naming and helper-code issues and challenged exposing a fixed chunk size through tableam; Robert and Tom Lane favored keeping the refactoring separate from algorithm changes #9 #12 #13 #14.
- Alvaro Herrera reviewed, compiled, and checked the headers of the file split, then supplied a rebase with a whitespace correction; Robert committed that version unchanged as 8b94dab066 and reposted the remaining work #16 #17.
- The reusable insertion/deletion helper component from #17 landed unchanged as bd124996ef, leaving the alternative-AM implementation and function renaming for further work #23.
- Andres Freund and Tom Lane questioned the fixed per-AM chunk-size interface, and Robert explained that inferring chunk sizes during sliced reads could return incorrect data or require extra reads, leaving the generalization unresolved #18 #20 #24.
- Robert committed the renaming component from #23 as 2e8b6bfa90, rebasing it ahead of the unresolved AM changes, and reposted the final outstanding patch #25.
- Prabhat reported a checkpointer crash while testing the outstanding patch; Ashutosh Sharma investigated fsync failure paths, subsequent tests could not reproduce it, and Robert concluded that the failure was unrelated to the TOAST changes #26 #29 #36 #37 #40.
- Peter Eisentraut considered the existing API restructuring workable, but Andres argued that chunk sizing belonged inside the AM; Robert proposed delegating detoasting itself, and Andres favored one callback supporting both whole-value and sliced access #30 #31 #32 #34.
- Robert replaced the slot-based generalization with two preparatory patches that cleaned up detoasting and extracted heap_fetch_toast_slice, leaving a reusable slot-based helper unimplemented #41.
- Peter questioned the new abstraction's complexity, and Robert clarified that choosing the TOAST-table AM and decoding values were separate operations, with the new callback allowing more flexibility than merely changing chunk size #44 #45.
- Peter's detailed cleanup review led to clearer variable names, restored chunk-count diagnostics, and a stricter assertion; Robert then posted a complete four-patch series combining those changes with TOAST-AM selection and relation_fetch_toast_slice #46 #47.
- The cleanup component of #47 landed unchanged as d5406dea25, but Robert immediately reported a bug and a follow-up fix; the reposted remainder incorporates a corrected final-chunk size calculation instead of the faulty modulo expression #48.
- The extraction component of #48 landed as e9fd0415e6 with comment typos corrected, leaving only the two tableam interface patches #49.
- The final submission #49 supplied TOAST-AM selection unchanged for 83322e38da and the detoasting callback for ce242ae154, whose only additional edit simplified a scan-key comment.
- Robert confirmed both final patches were committed and declared his intended work complete; the earlier exposed chunk-size design had been superseded by AM-controlled detoasting #50.