model-writtenrun 9116 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Thomas Munro opened the investigation with an intermittent Parallel Append ordering failure on aye-aye in #1, then demonstrated that ANALYZE could change the plan and suggested explicitly analyzing the inheritance tables in #3.
- Tom Lane wanted to explain the unexpected statistics before changing maintenance commands in #4, while David Rowley warned against ANALYZE inside a parallel test group and supplied an inline maintenance-counter probe in #5.
- Tom Lane found twelve similar failures confined to pg_upgrade testing in #6, expanded the proposed probes to include relpages and reltuples in #7, and committed them as f03a9ca436, adding a second observation point in stats.sql to account for collector lag.
- Thomas Munro reported a zero vacuum counter after the instrumentation landed in #8, but Tom Lane explained that correct tuple estimates pointed to lost collector messages in #9; Noah Misch identified small WAL segments and extra databases as distinctive pg_upgrade test conditions in #10.
- After frequent failures in the new counter queries, Tom Lane proposed removing those probes in #11, then found a recorded failure showing a_star with zero relpages and reltuples despite a reported vacuum in #12.
- Andres Freund explained how inheritance-sensitive size estimation might expose otherwise hidden zero statistics in #13, and Tom Lane identified a concrete mechanism in #15: ordinary VACUUM can skip a single pinned page and leave its table statistics unchanged.
- Tom Lane considered CHECKPOINT before VACUUM in #15, Andres Freund suggested DEBUG2 logging or VACUUM FREEZE in #16, and Tom preferred targeted ANALYZE while noting possible inheritance-statistics effects in #17.
- Thomas Munro linked clusters of collector failures to shared hosts and possible UDP buffer pressure in #18 and #19; Tom Lane then confirmed the diagnostic cleanup in #20, implemented by b43f7c117e, retaining only the select_parallel page/tuple probe.
- A further archived failure showed zero statistics for d_star and changed worker counts, leading Tom Lane to stop waiting for more evidence and post explicit ANALYZE commands for all six tables in #21, with backpatching proposed only through v12.
- The last message, #21, proposed both final diagnostic removal and the corrective patch; the next day d9cacca2d1 removed the remaining probe and b9bffa004a landed the ANALYZE attachment unchanged, including a v12 backport.