model-writtenrun 9230 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Vignesh proposed removing apparently unnecessary includes from ten backend files after successful local compilation and regression tests in #1, then described an automated Perl-based cleanup in #3; Amit suggested integration with patch testing in #4.
- Andres warned that successful compilation can conceal dependencies on indirectly included headers, identifying concrete problems in freepage.c and portalmem.c in #7; Tom and Alvaro pointed to existing pginclude tooling and its history of breakage in #8 and #9.
- Discussion shifted toward reducing dependencies between headers: Andres advocated struct forward declarations in #10 and #13, while Alvaro and Tom explored separating typedefs from definitions and centralizing Node typedefs in #11, #12 and #14, without settling a general redesign.
- Andres supplied an independent four-patch series in #15 covering redundant SQL-function prototypes, the acl.h dependency on array.h, unnecessary fmgr.h includes and more controversial removals from headers whose macros depend on fmgr.h.
- Vignesh restored the two specifically challenged includes in #16, but Alvaro found the same underlying problem remained elsewhere, including dsa.c's direct use of LWLocks, and recommended rejecting the broader patch in #17; Tom reinforced the portability concerns in #18.
- Alvaro extracted only the unnecessary limits.h inclusion in sharedtuplestore.c from #16 as e1f4c481b9 and declared that cleanup finished in #19; Thomas subsequently explained the include's likely origin and discussed standalone header compilation in #20.
- Andres committed the first three components of #15 without substantive changes as 0ae2dc4db2, 6a04d345fd and fb3b098fe8, but left the macro-dependent fourth patch uncommitted pending support from another reviewer, as explained in #22.
- Tom's standalone-header checks exposed missing FmgrInfo declarations in selfuncs.h after the fmgr.h cleanup and an independent missing PGconn declaration in scripts_parallel.h in #23; he also supplied a C-based headerscheck script because the existing C++ checker missed the former failure.
- Tom fixed scripts_parallel.h by adding libpq-fe.h in 5f110933e1, then updated his checker and reported successful checks on Linux, FreeBSD and macOS apart from selfuncs.h in #24.
- After Alvaro supported including the checker in #25, Tom committed headerscheck, its make target and documentation as 55ea109188, confirming the landing in #26.
- Andres repaired selfuncs.h with a direct fmgr.h include in 4c01a11103 and confirmed the fix in #27; Tom's role was reporting the failure, with no subsequent review of that fix shown.
- The thread ended with Andres identifying -fsyntax-only as the reason the C++ checker missed the failure and proposing shared exclusion markers and make-based parallel checks in #27 and #28; Alvaro supplied an older approach in #29, while Tom questioned the compiler flag but resisted extensive script redesign in #30, leaving those tooling ideas and the fourth header-cleanup patch unresolved.