model-writtenrun 9099 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Michael Paquier revived session start/end hooks after the previous attempt's Windows testing failure had been addressed, simplifying the test module and fixing hook chaining, SQL quoting, and function declarations in #1.
- Testing by legrand legrand exposed differences in which process types reached each hook, while Michael explained the startup paths and corrected the stale copyright in #2, #3, and #5; Mike Palmiotto proposed coordination with his process-startup centralization work in #4.
- FabrÃzio de Royes Mello suggested initially restricting hooks to normal backends, but accepted Michael's argument for leaving filtering to hook users and reported successful regression tests in #6, #7, and #8.
- Michael committed #1 as e788bd924c, adding database-validity checks after finding that the autovacuum launcher could reach the end hook without a database connection, as explained in #9.
- After the commit was reverted, Andres Freund identified unsafe shutdown-hook placement, hot-standby restrictions, inconsistent process coverage, and missing guidance in #10; Tom Lane explained the need for intact subsystems, transaction and error cleanup, and race-free shutdown tests in #11.
- Michael floated callback priorities and discussed hook documentation in #12 and #13, while Andres emphasized that arbitrary writes during fatal exits were unsafe and that hook placement needed explicit justification in #14.
- Michael posted a start-only revision in #15, dropping the end hook because the necessary facilities were lacking, adding defensive checks to the sample module, and fixing Windows test authentication setup.
- Andres rejected the revised interface as still insufficiently designed in #16, and FabrÃzio proposed narrowing its scope to client backends and background workers in #17.
- Andres proposed lifecycle callbacks with explicit stages and restrictions, distinguishing normal exits from fatal errors, in #18; Mike suggested integrating that design with his process-centralization work in #19.
- Takayuki Tsunakawa reopened the discussion with a plan-cache warm-up use case and a SQL-level connection-trigger proposal in #20, and Michael confirmed that the committed hooks remained reverted pending a better lifecycle design in #21.
- Alvaro Herrera questioned the misleading committed status, Tom Lane recommended returning the patch with feedback because the concept remained viable, and Michael confirmed the status correction in #22, #23, #24, and #25; no replacement implementation landed within this thread.