model-writtenrun 9134 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Andres Freund proposed generating node metadata with libclang and using generic routines to avoid maintaining copy/equal/out/read functions manually; his initial prototype measured node-tree memory usage and left array-length handling unresolved #1.
- Fabien COELHO described an abandoned Perl generator, warned about exceptional field semantics, and suggested either lightweight C parsing or generating structures and utility functions from authoritative metadata #2 #3.
- Andres expanded the prototype into a twelve-patch series with typed arrays carrying their lengths, generic node operations, generated metadata checked into the source tree, and single-allocation copying that substantially reduced cached-plan memory in his example #4.
- The expanded series also introduced frontend StringInfo support for the metadata generator, numeric formatting improvements, precise float serialization and a revised node text format; Andres reported less than five percent slowdown in his copy/read/write testing and identified cleanup and tokenizer optimization as remaining work #4.
- Andres suggested using JSON for node serialization to reuse existing parsing and inspection tools, and David Fetter supported the direction, but no attached revision implemented it #5 #6.
- Robert Haas considered the metadata approach promising if libclang interfaces remained stable across versions, while Tom Lane opposed requiring LLVM for node-definition changes and preferred Perl tooling or an authoritative schema with semantic annotations #7 #8 #9 #10.
- Andres reported identical generated output with libclang 3.7 and his development version after compatibility adjustments, proposed reducing metadata renumbering by inlining field information and strings, and explained how typed arrays already handled length relationships; Robert found the portability argument persuasive #11 #12 #13.
- Andres committed the StringInfo prerequisite from #4 as 26aaf97b68, retaining the header location and frontend size limit while narrowing pg_waldump changes and adding documentation and Windows build support.
- The final message returned to serialization efficiency: David Rowley proposed hexadecimal or base64 numeric output and denser Bitmapset encoding #14; the supplied record establishes the StringInfo prerequisite's landing, while the broader metadata implementation and serialization choices remained unresolved.