model-writtenrun 8748 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Andres Freund opened #1 with a broad prototype to accelerate interpreted and JIT expression evaluation and enable eventual JIT caching, combining specialized opcodes, denser allocations, builder objects, and relative references that LLVM could optimize.
- After Soumyadeep Chakraborty examined function references in #2, Andres clarified in #3 that llvmjit_types supplied accurate signatures, while resolving PL-handler names addressed a separate source of embedded function pointers.
- Andreas Karlsson found that the experimental isinf implementation failed to compile with clang 7 in #4, and Andres said he would drop that peripheral patch in #5.
- Soumyadeep supplied function-signature lookup, PL-handler resolution, and early function-optimization patches on top of the prototype in #6; Andres requested independent applicability, forced-JIT regression testing, on-demand signature lookup, and measurements of the optimization benefit in #7.
- Soumyadeep revised the signature and handler patches in #8, adopting on-demand lookup, rebasing the handler change onto master, and reporting forced-JIT testing with failures he also observed on unpatched trees.
- On February 7, 2020, the cleanup components of #1 landed together as 1ec7679f1b, redundant AggState storage was removed by 1fdb7f9789, and IOCOERCE function-name references landed as 8c2769405f, all with matching component changes.
- The same landing round extracted opcode-emission consolidation from #1 into e6f86f8dd9, adapting it to master and extending consolidation to temporary assignments and strict function calls.
- Andres explained in #9 how he expanded Soumyadeep's signature-lookup patch from #8 into b059d2f456, centralizing lookups, converting additional calls, and removing redundant function globals.
- The early function-optimization proposal remained unproven: after Andres requested clarification in #10, Soumyadeep supplied smaller dumped-bitcode sizes in #12 but explicitly left their practical memory benefit uncertain.
- Soumyadeep resubmitted the remaining PL-handler patch in #13, fixing external-library names and reporting forced-JIT regression and plsh tests.
- The aggregate-transition component of #1 landed on February 24, 2020 as 2742c45080, retaining combined transition opcodes and inline helpers while refining interpreter control flow and comments.
- Soumyadeep extended the original relative-allocation design in #14 to allocate FmgrInfo objects similarly to FunctionCallInfo, but initialization still embedded pointers and left caching questions unresolved.
- The broader work stalled after Daniel Gustafsson requested a consolidated submission for CI in #15, and Michael Paquier marked it Returned with Feedback in #16.
- Robert Haas reopened substantive review in #17, identifying allocation arithmetic problems and questioning naming, documentation, list construction, and the relative-pointer interface.
- Andres reported a rebased branch with some patches dropped and another aggregate pointer eliminated in #18, while acknowledging that FunctionCallInfo context and flinfo references still blocked the intended caching design.
- Robert proposed lifetime-managed allocations in #19, but Andres explained in #20 that recursive execution required separate mutable storage and in #22 that sharing JIT code across connections also ruled out embedded process-specific pointers.
- Robert suggested reusing utils/relptr.h in #24; at the thread's final message, #25, Andres accepted exploring that direction but still favored offsets for mutable data, leaving the larger caching and expression-reuse work unfinished.
- The original fast-path proposal later continued in thread #48583, whose #581998 supplied the final versions for 8dd7c7cd0a and d35d32d711 in March 2025.