model-writtenrun 8996 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Amit Kapila opened the costing discussion #1 to prevent parallel vacuum workers from multiplying the intended I/O allowance, comparing Masahiko Sawada's shared-balance prototype with Dilip Kumar's divided-budget prototype from thread #39201.
- Darafei Praliaskouski proposed system-wide IOPS limits #2, while Masahiko Sawada and Andres Freund explained how unequal cache residency and worker workloads could defeat fair throttling or make divided budgets unnecessarily slow #6 #8.
- Jeff Janes questioned the benefit of parallelism under I/O throttling #7; Andres Freund identified CPU-bound cases and possible ring-buffer overhead #9, and Dilip's measurements showed that parallel vacuum retained a benefit with larger or disabled ring buffers #18 #20.
- Stephen Frost raised independent tablespace I/O budgets #12, but Andres Freund and Amit Kapila argued that redesigning tablespace throttling should remain separate from the parallel-vacuum patch #13 #17.
- Amit briefly proposed enabling parallel vacuum only without throttling #21, but Andres insisted that the feature needed a throttling solution #22, and Amit resumed exploring the costing approaches #23.
- Amit proposed combining a shared cost limit with a local threshold and delays proportional to each worker's accumulated cost #25; Sawada identified possible overshoot #27, prompting experiments with a threshold of half a worker's nominal share #28.
- Dilip reproduced unfair delay distribution and compared local-threshold alternatives #29, then posted instrumentation and three experimental patches #31, finding that sleeping for local cost and subtracting only that cost from the shared balance distributed delays more fairly.
- Amit found that the prototype divided by 0.5 instead of multiplying by it #33; Dilip corrected the formula and tested several thresholds #36, then replaced the fixed worker count with a dynamic active-worker count #37.
- Although Dilip's experiments showed little sensitivity to the threshold, Amit recommended retaining it for other workloads and requested independent testing #38.
- Sawada reproduced the results across buffer sizes, delays and worker counts #40, and Mahendra Singh Thalor confirmed improved proportionality across different index and worker counts while observing small total-delay differences #41.
- Amit summarized the shared-balance, local-threshold approach as the preferred design #42; Dilip attributed remaining delay differences to varying cache misses and incomplete diagnostic reporting, supplying total-delay instrumentation that showed nearly identical serial and parallel totals #43.
- The thread ended with Sawada agreeing to the approach #44, leaving integration to the main parallel-vacuum series rather than recording a landing here.
- The costing design subsequently appeared in 40d964ec99 as part of parallel index vacuum, with the latest integrated patch attributed to #441099 in thread #39201; the committed implementation extracted compute_parallel_delay(), used atomic addition/subtraction, and omitted this thread's diagnostic instrumentation.