model-writtenrun 8831 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Fujii Masao proposed pg_file_sync() in #1 to make files written by pg_file_write() or COPY TO durable, with support for directories, restricted execution privileges, tests, documentation, and an adminpack version upgrade.
- Arthur Zakirov identified that using fsync_fname() could cause PANIC on permission failures in #3, and Michael Paquier raised file-opening race concerns in #4; Fujii exported and reused fsync_fname_ext() with ERROR severity in #5 to avoid PANIC and duplicated code.
- Julien Rouhaud's proposal to make rename and unlink durable prompted a separate semantics discussion: Fujii opposed imposing the performance cost in #6, Julien accepted separate work in #7, and Stephen Frost and Tom Lane supported preserving filesystem-style operations in #9 and #11.
- Julien requested clearer documentation and automatic execution privileges for pg_write_server_files in #8; Fujii adopted the wording in #12 but retained explicit grants for consistency with other adminpack functions, and Stephen confirmed that the existing privilege policy was intentional in #23.
- Michael questioned the always-true boolean result and the cost of syncing global in #13, while Arthur and Atsushi Torikoshi discussed error semantics in #16 and #21; Robert Haas advocated void with ERROR in #26, and Michael endorsed that combination in #27.
- Fujii implemented void-on-success and ERROR-on-failure in #28, also switching the directory test to pg_stat; he explained in #29 that this avoided the test cost and left possible directory-creation functions for separate work.
- Arthur reported successful compilation, regression tests, and documentation builds in #30; Michael and Arthur then requested an explicit explanation of the function's independence from data_sync_retry in #31 and #33, which Fujii added in #34.
- Julien requested an explicit corruption warning in #35, but Fujii considered that excessive in #36; Fujii committed #34 unchanged as d694e0bb79 and announced completion in #37, leaving further discussion of the documentation open.