model-writtenrun 8844 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Andres Freund reported that SlabCheck leaked its free-chunk bitmap into TopMemoryContext, degrading assertion-build performance, and noted that palloc could also violate the checker's error-handling requirements #1.
- Tom Lane argued that allocating memory during a memory-context check assumes the allocator is already sound #2; Andres explored persistent shared storage and a denser stack bitmap #3 #5, while Tomas Vondra favored allocating the storage with each context for simplicity #6.
- Tomas submitted a patch that reserves bitmap storage in the SlabContext header under MEMORY_CONTEXT_CHECKING, eliminating allocations during SlabCheck; he left denser bitmap storage out because the existing boolean array was sufficient #8.
- Tom reviewed the patch and requested a bool* declaration, removal of unnecessary alignment, and clearer comments #9; Tomas agreed to incorporate those edits #12.
- Andres questioned allocating a bitmap per context instead of sharing one globally #10; Tomas defended the simpler management of differing chunk counts #11, and Tom noted that per-context storage is reclaimed when the contexts disappear #13.
- Andres demonstrated severe pgbench degradation from the leak and explained that additional slab contexts in his local work exposed it #14; Tom invited a separate patch to evaluate the shared-storage alternative #15.
- Tomas raised a possible extension compatibility concern about changing the structure #16, but Tom explained that SlabContext is private to slab.c and advocated backpatching given the performance impact #17; Tomas accepted that reasoning #18.
- Tomas committed the attached patch with the light review edits as 543852fd8b and confirmed backpatching through PostgreSQL 10 #19.
- The thread ended with the leak fixed and backpatched; Tomas estimated that existing slab contexts require only small boolean arrays and noted that a denser bitmap could reduce their size, leaving shared-storage optimization as a possible future improvement #20.