model-writtenrun 7769 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Nathan Bossart proposed independent main-relation and secondary-relation VACUUM controls in #1, aiming to let table owners target TOAST tables without discovering their names or obtaining pg_toast access, while retaining the existing main-relation locking and ownership checks.
- After Vik Fearing questioned the manual-vacuum use case in #2, Nathan explained that main and TOAST relations can have substantially different bloat or transaction ages in #4, and Michael Paquier described similar experience in #7.
- Michael argued for a TOAST-specific name and questioned rejecting a command with both cleanup options disabled in #3; Nathan adopted those changes and positive internal flags in #5, then allowed ANALYZE with main-relation cleanup disabled in #8.
- Justin Pryzby supplied vacuumdb support and corrected the FULL error wording in #10; Nathan folded those changes into #11, adding documentation, TAP tests, and analyze-only checks while suggesting that arbitrary vacuumdb option forwarding deserved a separate discussion.
- Kirk Jamison reviewed the combined patch in #12, questioned documentation and TOAST recursion details, suggested splitting the backend and client changes for readability, and reported successful regression and TAP tests.
- Michael questioned the need for MAIN_RELATION_CLEANUP and its added vacuum_rel() complexity in #13, with Masahiko Sawada supporting a simpler interface in #15; Nathan defended accessibility for ordinary table owners in #14, but Michael noted that pg_toast access could be granted in #16 and returned the inactive proposal with feedback in #17.
- Justin revived the thread with a maintenance-script use case for independently freezing main and TOAST relations in #18; Nathan responded with #19, dropping MAIN_RELATION_CLEANUP and exposing only the existing internal ability to skip TOAST processing.
- Justin argued that CLEANUP understated the freezing use case and asked whether FULL should ignore the option in #20; Nathan and Michael favored an explicit error and a PROCESS-based name in #21 and #22, leading to PROCESS_TOAST in #23.
- Michael supplied #24, aligning the internal flag with PROCESS_TOAST and adjusting its callers; Justin's wording review in #25 was incorporated into Nathan's final patch in #26.
- Michael committed #26 as 7cb3048f38 with light comment, completion-order, test-formatting, and help-text edits, adding PROCESS_TOAST and vacuumdb --no-process-toast, and announced application in #27.
- The thread ended with Nathan's acknowledgment in #28: the reduced TOAST-control feature had landed, while MAIN_RELATION_CLEANUP had been dropped because direct TOAST vacuuming already existed and reviewers considered the additional backend complexity unjustified.