model-writtenrun 8818 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Ian Lawrence Barwick proposed preventing pg_basebackup from running as root after encountering an operational problem, attaching a check that still permits --help and --version and omitting documentation changes to follow similar utilities #1.
- Michael Paquier supported preventing incompatible data-directory ownership, suggested clearer commentary and consistent diagnostics, identified an indentation error, and recommended against backpatching because this changes behavior #2.
- Ian revised the comment and indentation while retaining diagnostics consistent with initdb and pg_ctl, rejecting an overly broad claim about other users' permissions; Michael accepted those choices and favored retaining flexibility in each utility's error messages over standardizing them #3 #4.
- Michael committed the revised patch as 7bae0ad9fc, with only comment rewrapping and no backpatch, and announced the landing in #5.
- The thread ended with Andres Freund reporting that the change had been reverted, at least temporarily, following a separate discussion; his message does not explain the substantive reason or provide a replacement patch #7.