model-writtenrun 8745 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Tom Lane proposed removing the opaque pseudo-type and its compatibility conversions for datatype I/O, triggers, and language handlers, arguing that conventions superseded in PostgreSQL 7.3 were obsolete #1.
- Tom Lane favored retaining automatic shell-type creation during C input-function declarations because it remained type-safe and required little supporting code #1.
- Tom Lane submitted two patches separating the more involved CREATE TYPE simplification from the remaining opaque removal; the first moved I/O return-type checks into lookup functions and simplified shell-type handling #2.
- Tom Lane committed both patches together as bb03010b9f, preserving the changes submitted in #2 and adding a catalog-version bump.
- After the commit, Andres Freund supported removing opaque and mildly favored also removing automatic shell-type creation, arguing that further delay would not ease migration; the submitted series had landed, while that broader removal remained a suggestion #3.