model-writtenrun 7634 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- James Coleman proposed replacing the misleading startup error for a standby with hot_standby disabled in #1; Andres Freund explained that the connection-state enum was internal and recommended using postmaster state rather than checking recovery LSNs in #2 and #4.
- James posted the first implementation in #5 without automated tests, and David Zhang tested it against a primary and standby and demonstrated the changed error messages in #6.
- Fujii Masao discovered that PM_RECOVERY also occurs with hot_standby enabled before consistency is reached in #8, prompting James to add an EnableHotStandby check in #9 and later rebase the patch in #11.
- After a several-month gap, Fujii challenged the contradictory descriptions of the same recovery state in #13, and Alvaro Herrera proposed a common connection-rejection message with separate details explaining consistency or disabled hot standby in #15.
- Fujii preferred reporting disabled hot standby regardless of consistency to avoid adding a startup-process signal and postmaster state in #16; Magnus Hagander supported that choice in #17, and Alvaro acknowledged that no new signal or postmaster state was necessary in #23.
- James's revision in #26 changed the messages but omitted separate DETAIL fields, so Fujii supplied #27 with those fields and a dedicated recovery rejection case; James initially retained his own state-selection layout while incorporating the details in #28.
- Fujii explained in #29 and #31 that normal startup and crash recovery should retain the original startup message, while archive recovery should distinguish disabled hot standby from waiting for consistency; James adopted Fujii's recovery-case structure with the name CAC_NOTCONSISTENT in #32.
- Alvaro suggested making the temporary nature of recovery rejection explicit in #33, Tom Lane refined the wording in #34, and James incorporated it in #35.
- Further discussion established that PM_STARTUP can persist during crash recovery: Fujii clarified this in #36, Alvaro proposed an explanatory detail in #37, and Tom rejected that detail because postmaster cannot reliably distinguish crash recovery from normal startup in #38.
- Fujii restored the original startup message and applied pgindent in #41, then committed that attachment unchanged as df9384492b, crediting James as author and announcing completion in #43.
- The thread ended with James thanking the reviewers and committer in #44; the proposed change had landed, with no remaining patch or follow-up fix under discussion.