model-writtenrun 8680 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Jeff Davis proposed an AllocSet-specific chunk-space estimator to improve hash aggregation planning, group limits and initial table sizing, accounting for chunk headers and allocation rounding in #1.
- Jeff supplied a context-aware alternative covering AllocSet, Generation and Slab in #2, but preferred the original simplicity because the planner lacks the eventual execution context and must substitute CurrentMemoryContext.
- Andres Freund opposed direct allocator-specific calls and questioned precise overhead estimates for poorly estimated transition values in #3; Jeff defended accounting for allocation overhead and asked which interface to pursue in #4.
- Andres favored a constant overhead estimate or eliminating allocation overhead altogether in #5; Jeff considered allocation restructuring too disruptive for the current release and offered an approximate formula as a fallback in the thread’s final message, #6.
- Jeff subsequently committed 0588ee63aa, preserving the allocation breakdown from #2 while replacing the proposed allocator interfaces with a fixed 16-byte chunk overhead; allocator restructuring and precise rounding estimates were left out.