model-writtenrun 8190 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Andres Freund reported that the default configuration unnecessarily acquired SyncRepLock exclusively on every commit, adding contention even without synchronous standbys configured #1.
- Masahiko Sawada proposed a shared-lock check #2, and Ashwin Agrawal supplied an inline alternative combining configuration and shared-state checks #3; Andres rejected an additional lock acquisition and recommended checking the shared flag directly with compiler protection #4, which Sawada and Ashwin considered safe #5 #6.
- Fujii Masao posted the first attached patch, adding a volatile unlocked check of sync_standbys_defined while retaining the later locked check #7; Sawada requested explanatory comments, and their discussion established that checking the flag and manipulating the wait queue must remain atomic to prevent indefinite waits #8 #11 #12.
- After a pause, Fujii questioned whether a memory barrier was necessary #16; Asim Praveen and Robert Haas explained why a barrier would not address the concern, while identifying a separate configuration-propagation window in which a standby could appear synchronous before commits began waiting for it #17 #18.
- Sawada and Fujii confirmed that the standby-status problem existed independently of this patch #20 #21, and Asim marked the optimization ready for a committer #22; Kyotaro Horiguchi and Sawada discussed possible status-reporting changes, but no implementation of that separate issue was attached in this thread #24 #25.
- Following requests from Sawada and Kyotaro to explain the unlocked check, Fujii expanded the comments and moved the fast exit ahead of wait-mode calculation #8 #23 #26; Asim's review then prompted a typo correction and clearer explanation that an early return does not touch the queue #27 #28.
- Asim and Sawada accepted the final comments #29 #30, and Fujii committed #28 unchanged as be9788e998, announcing the push in #31.
- The thread ended with Andres thanking the contributors #32; the lock-avoidance patch had landed, while the separate standby-status propagation issue discussed in #21 and #24 remained unresolved here.