model-writtenrun 8427 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- The thread opened with Alvaro Herrera's announcement that FETCH FIRST WITH TIES had landed using Surafel Temesgen's implementation, while Andrew Gierth's more ambitious alternative remained unfinished #1.
- Julien Rouhaud found that GCC 9.3 rejected a fall-through in the new LIMIT state machine and supplied an assertion plus an annotation immediately before the next case label #2.
- Tom Lane accepted the small fix while noting that the state-machine logic deserved clearer explanation #3; he committed Julien's patch with rewritten comments as 35cb574aa8.
- Tom Lane also proposed enabling the warning by default #3, prompting Julien Rouhaud's configure patch for both C and C++ #4.
- Tom Lane recommended level 4 to constrain accepted annotation spellings #5, and Julien Rouhaud revised the configure patch accordingly #7.
- Alvaro Herrera found that level 4 produced 217 warnings because existing annotations used spaces #10; after Tom Lane reaffirmed the stricter setting #12, Julien Rouhaud supplied widespread FALLTHRU normalization #13.
- Andrew Dunstan proposed retaining level 3 for externally maintained zic.c #14, and Julien Rouhaud supplied an inline Makefile approach #15; learning that level 4 also rejected lowercase annotations led Tom Lane to favor level 3 overall #18.
- Alvaro Herrera nevertheless committed the expanded patch at level 4 as 3e9744465d, choosing FALLTHROUGH spelling and replacing the zic.c edits with a target-specific Makefile override #20.
- Alvaro Herrera reported fixing a remaining contrib annotation and discovered that ccache could reuse warnings after comment-only edits #21; Tom Lane opposed switching to GCC-specific fall-through attributes and preferred retaining comments #23.
- Kyotaro Horiguchi reported warnings in code generated by Bison 3.0.4 #24, and Andy Fan reported that upgrading Bison avoided them #25; Tom Lane reproduced the problem with Bison 3.0.5 and rejected raising the minimum supported Bison version #28.
- Tom Lane requested level 3 globally and reversal of the annotation churn to avoid back-patching difficulties #30; Alvaro Herrera implemented that decision in 17cc133f01 and confirmed completion #32.
- The thread ended with the warning enabled at level 3, the original LIMIT fix retained, and the level-4 annotation changes undone; Andy Fan confirmed that lowering the warning level resolved the Bison issue #33.