model-writtenrun 8625 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Michael Paquier reported that current pg_basebackup failed against PostgreSQL 12 and older unless users supplied --no-manifest, and proposed silently disabling unsupported manifests in #1.
- David Steele initially questioned silently skipping a default feature in #2, but accepted Stephen Frost's compatibility argument in #3 and warned that forcing --no-manifest into shared scripts could also disable manifests for PostgreSQL 13 in #4; Andres Freund suggested at least providing an explanatory hint in #5.
- Michael submitted #7, adding MINIMUM_VERSION_FOR_MANIFESTS, disabling manifests after connecting to older servers, and simplifying BASE_BACKUP option construction.
- Kyotaro Horiguchi preferred an error with instructions and reported a confusing option-conflict error in #8, but withdrew that report as possibly coming from an unpatched build and did not oppose the compatibility approach in #10.
- Robert Haas questioned whether removing the explicit MANIFEST 'no' clause would break --no-manifest in #11; Michael demonstrated that the protocol default, server code, and existing TAP test supported the removal in #12, and Robert withdrew his concern in #14.
- Alvaro Herrera supported silent disabling to avoid encouraging bad scripts in #13, Robert authorized proceeding in #16, and Tom Lane endorsed the compatibility behavior in #19.
- Michael committed #7 unchanged as 542d7817f7 and confirmed completion in #20, leaving no outstanding patch revisions.