model-writtenrun 8594 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Peter Eisentraut reported that table access method changes had broken HEAPDEBUGALL since PostgreSQL 12 and proposed removing it, while asking whether the working HEAPAMSLOTDEBUGALL should remain; Tom Lane supported removing both as low-value debugging features #1 #2.
- Alexander Lakhin broadened the cleanup by reporting that enabling HAVE_ALLOCINFO failed to compile in generation.c, and Peter Eisentraut requested a patch #3 #4.
- Alexander Lakhin submitted the removal patch after finding that slab tracing was also broken and that the working aset.c tracing produced a 3.8 GB regression-test log, making it impractical without additional filtering #7.
- After an initial removal announcement and Tom Lane's query about the missing commit, Peter Eisentraut landed the discussion-driven removal of both heap tracing macros as aaf069aa34 and confirmed the push #5 #6 #8.
- Tom Lane proposed also removing ACLDEBUG, the remaining undocumented debug symbol in pg_config_manual.h, and supported the allocation-tracing cleanup because tools such as Valgrind offered better memory analysis #9 #10.
- Tom Lane subsequently checked Alexander Lakhin's allocation-tracing patch more closely and committed #7 unchanged as ee88ef55db, confirming completion in #12.
- Tom Lane also implemented the ACLDEBUG removal directly from the discussion as 3436c5e283 and confirmed it in #13.
- The thread ended with Michael Paquier's agreement after all three cleanups had landed, with no remaining patch or unresolved implementation question identified #14.