model-writtenrun 8269 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Peter Geoghegan opened the thread with shared-buffer pin instrumentation adapted from Álvaro Herrera's earlier work, stricter nbtree lock instrumentation, and two page-deletion fixes found by running regression tests under Valgrind; a separate, more serious unpinned-access problem still needed a fix #1.
- The first early fix landed as fa7ff642c2, taking the cached-left-sibling check from #1 and adding explanatory comments instead of reading page metadata after unlocking.
- The second early fix landed as 7154aa16a6, moving the top-parent read before unlocking as proposed in #1, with additional branch cleanup, an assertion, and comments.
- Peter resent the remaining instrumentation in #2, explaining that all nbtree locking must use wrappers and that generic pin instrumentation restores accessibility after errors; local buffers remain excluded from NOACCESS marking to avoid false positives.
- After Daniel Gustafsson reported conflicts in #3, Peter supplied the rebased series in #4; Georgios Kokolatos reviewed the instrumentation design and commentary but reported difficulty locating the latest series in #5.
- Anastasia Lubennikova found that the _bt_conditionallockbuf() comment incorrectly required every successful caller to run _bt_checkpage(), and otherwise marked the series ready for committer #6.
- Peter committed the generic buffer-pin component of #4 as 1e0dfd166b, adding configuration documentation, and explained that a uniform pin-and-lock rule was preferable even where older nbtree accesses were arguably safe; extending the checks to other access methods was not planned immediately #7.
- Tom Lane reported a possible related buildfarm failure in #8, prompting Peter's follow-up patch to make PinBuffer() mark memory defined even when BM_VALID is unset #9; the supplied candidate list does not establish that fix's landing.
- After acknowledging Georgios's delayed review in #10, Peter committed the nbtree component of #4 as 4a70f829d8, correcting Anastasia's comment issue and expanding documentation without changing the wrapper logic, then announced completion in #11.
- The thread ended with Georgios acknowledging the review exchange in #12; both main instrumentation components and the two original page-deletion fixes had landed, while the follow-up fix's disposition was not explicitly reported here.