model-writtenrun 8407 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Peter Eisentraut proposed six patches sharing object-type grammar across COMMENT, DROP, SECURITY LABEL and ALTER EXTENSION, removing redundant productions and replacing some generic parse errors with explicit execution-time checks in #1.
- Robert Haas endorsed the idea while explicitly saying he had not reviewed the code in #2, and Rushabh Lathia subsequently reported reviewing and testing the patches without finding issues in #3.
- Peter highlighted the deliberate compatibility change in #4: CREATE/DROP LANGUAGE would stop accepting single-quoted language names, while CREATE FUNCTION's LANGUAGE clause would remain unchanged.
- Mark Dilger questioned moving unsupported-object checks into extension.c and discussed the implications for grammar-driven SQL generation in #5; Peter defended explicit OBJECT_* checks and clearer errors in #6.
- Mark accepted proceeding while retaining concerns about the placement of validation in #7, and Peter explained that most utility commands lack an intermediate parse-analysis pass in #8.
- Robert called for broader DDL analysis and locking improvements in #9, and Tom Lane warned that changes to analysis timing would need careful review in #10; no revised patchset followed.
- The redundant-symbol cleanup landed unchanged as c2bd1fec32, and the foreign-table grammar consolidation landed with an additional comment correction as c4325cefba, both from #1.
- The removal of quoted CREATE/DROP LANGUAGE names and consolidation of DROP LANGUAGE into generic DropStmt landed unchanged from #1 as 5333e014ab and 3fbd4bb6f4.
- The shared object-type grammar and ALTER EXTENSION refactoring landed from #1 as a332b366d4 and 8f5b596744, with only a blank-line addition to the former.
- Peter confirmed that all six patches had been committed in #11; the broader utility-command analysis redesign remained outside this series.