model-writtenrun 7941 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- David Rowley proposed routing constant ERROR-or-higher reports through a cold-attributed errstart_cold() wrapper in #1, aiming to improve instruction-cache use without editing thousands of error sites, and supplied initial performance measurements.
- Andres Freund reviewed the implementation in #3, suggesting __has_attribute detection, less macro duplication, possible inlining, and optimization of DEBUG reports; David explained in #4 that DEBUG calls should not make their surrounding normal execution paths cold.
- David supplied three alternative patches in #5, preserving the wrapper while simplifying feature detection and exploring unlikely() placement; experiments showed that inlining lost the desired cold hint, and performance varied across AMD and Intel hardware.
- After stabilizing his AMD machine, David reported modest TPC-H gains but little pgbench improvement in #8, suggesting that existing unlikely() annotations already captured much of the benefit.
- Peter Eisentraut proposed extending the cold-wrapper condition to DEBUG levels in #9, then withdrew that suggestion in #11 after David explained the risk to ordinary execution paths in #10; the retained patch covered ERROR-or-higher reports only.
- David resent the unchanged ERROR-only patch in #12 while considering abandonment because gains were difficult to reproduce, and longer TPC-H tests in #13 showed a small regression.
- Peter's Intel laptop tests in #18 showed substantial pgbench improvements, while his ARM laptop showed no change, providing the evidence David accepted in #19 to proceed.
- David split #12 into attribute definitions in 697e1d02f5 and error-path dispatch in 913ec71d68, announcing the landing in #20; the dispatch received explanatory comments, while the attribute guards were rewritten.
- Greg Nancarrow reported that the rewritten guards broke GCC 4.8.5 in #21 and cited the required separate existence test; David tested and committed that repair as 1fa22a43a5, confirming it in #22.
- Dagfinn Ilmari Mannsåker reiterated the simpler fallback definition in #23, and Peter noted in #24 that it had already been agreed earlier; David implemented that discussion-based cleanup and standardized attribute placement in b0727ae99b.
- Tom Lane reported a MinGW assembler failure on buildfarm animal walleye in #25; David considered disabling the attributes on MinGW in #27, while Tom requested a narrower exception in #28 and refined it to MinGW64 GCC 8.1 in #30 after Alvaro Herrera identified the compiler bug in #29.
- Tom favored upgrading walleye's compiler in #31, and David posted a temporary workaround in #33 while planning to contact its owner; Tom's final reply in #35 accepted that plan.
- The temporary workaround subsequently landed with only comment formatting changes as 687f616344; the original optimization and portability repairs were committed, with upgrading walleye and eventually removing its compiler exception left as follow-up work.