model-writtenrun 7934 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
Aug 2020 · 3 entries
- Alvaro Herrera opened the thread with #1, proposing a process flag so CREATE INDEX CONCURRENTLY on a small table would not wait for unrelated concurrent builds on larger tables.
- Tom Lane challenged the safety of ignoring index-building snapshots in #3 and #5, while James Coleman explained the distinction between ordinary indexes and indexes executing expressions in #6; Alvaro consequently restricted the flag to non-expression, non-partial indexes in #7.
- Michael Paquier proposed extending the optimization to REINDEX CONCURRENTLY and renaming vacuumFlags in #8; after the thread resumed in November, Dmitry Dolgov supplied the REINDEX extension in #10 and incorporated Michael's helper-extraction feedback from #11 into #20.
Nov - Dec 2020 · 14 entries
- Dmitry reported contention measurements in #20 that showed little additional cost from the proposed locking, and Alvaro committed that submission's naming prerequisite as cd9c1b3e19 with small documentation and formatting edits.
- Alvaro revised the remaining indexing patch in #24, questioning aggregate REINDEX safety and several transaction phases, then split prototype cleanup, lock relaxation, CREATE INDEX support and REINDEX support into #27.
- Michael's requests for locking documentation, safety explanations, assertions and a clearer helper name in #28 led to the revised remainder #29, while the lock-relaxation component landed separately as 27838981be.
- Andres Freund challenged the relaxed locking in #30 because concurrent snapshot and horizon calculations could observe inconsistent flag states, and Michael also questioned its justification in #33.
- While investigating locking, Alvaro found that ProcSleep formatted debugging strings while holding ProcArrayLock and posted #31; Michael's suggestion to skip unnecessary formatting in #35 was incorporated into the expanded patch #38.
- Tom objected to embedding logging-level policy in ProcSleep in #39, so 450c8230b1 landed the shorter critical section from #38 while retaining exclusive locking and leaving out the logging guard.
- Tom and Alvaro independently supplied message_level_is_interesting() implementations in #43 and #44, then discussed avoiding duplicate policy logic and function-call overhead in #45, #46 and #47.
- Tom combined those logging drafts in 789b938bf2, incorporating Alvaro's ProcSleep caller and factoring shared output policy into inline helpers with explicit error-level handling.
- Alvaro's flag-ordering analysis in #36 and Andres's memory-barrier explanation in #50 led to abandoning the lock relaxation; Alvaro additionally identified vacuum's premature snapshot acquisition in #54 and posted a corrective patch in #55.
- The CREATE INDEX portion of #29 landed as c98763bf51, with exclusive flag-update locking and revised comments, while flagging REINDEX sessions and using the flag for VACUUM horizons remained future work.
- The corrective patch #55 landed essentially unchanged as dcfff74fb1, restoring exclusive locking in the covered paths and setting vacuum flags before obtaining its snapshot.
- Returning to REINDEX, Alvaro explained in #57 that earlier versions missed transactions inside per-index loops and unnecessarily flagged transactions without snapshots; #58 replaced aggregate safety with per-index records and placed flag updates in the appropriate phases.
- Alvaro refined that design in #59 by caching table and access-method identifiers for progress reporting, while leaving a proposed cleanup of redundant relation-lock acquisitions unimplemented.
- Alvaro marked the commitfest item committed in #60 and said the remaining work would move to a new thread, leaving the revised REINDEX extension outside this thread's landed changes.
Nov 2021 · 1 entry
- Nearly a year later, Andres reported in #62 that the earlier restoration missed ReplicationSlotRelease; Alvaro acknowledged the mistake in #63 and fixed the remaining lock mode in 0726c764bc, backpatched to PostgreSQL 14, with Andres acknowledging completion in the final message #64.