model-writtenrun 8189 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Tom Lane proposed using nextXid as the vacuum cutoff for session-local temporary tables outside transaction blocks, attaching both the implementation and a GIN posting-tree vacuum test whose reliable coverage depended on it #1.
- Michael Paquier questioned whether static state could avoid passing isTopLevel through the call chain #2; Tom identified error-recovery overhead and state-lifetime concerns, considered portal state, and retained explicit parameter passing #3.
- On September 1, Tom committed the vacuum implementation with light cleanup as a7212be8b9 and the unchanged GIN test as 4c51a2d1e4, completing both patches from #1.
- After those commits, Andres Freund proposed replacing the top-level distinction with MyProc->xmin and moving the logic into horizon determination #4; after discussing VACUUM's transaction and snapshot handling #5 #6, Tom objected that the process xmin still depended on other sessions #7.
- Stephen Frost asked about broader visibility-based cleanup work #8, and Andres explained that his experimental approach remained limited by preserving intermediate versions in ctid chains and the cost of richer visibility lookups #9.
- Andres later proposed using latestCompletedXid and the current backend's transaction ID, allowing inexpensive centralized horizons and equally aggressive HOT pruning, and reported successful repeated tests of a patch developed alongside another thread #10.
- Peter Geoghegan suggested exploring the broader visibility idea in nbtree first, where avoiding page splits could justify expensive checks while sidestepping heap ctid-chain problems; that remained a separate design direction #11.
- The follow-up 94bc27b576, sourced from the newer patch in thread #42675, fixed inconsistent pruning and vacuum horizons by centralizing temporary-table handling in procarray.c, removing the earlier isTopLevel plumbing, and adding isolation tests.
- At the thread's close, Andres announced that the revised logic had landed and explained the latestCompletedXid + 1 cutoff for backends without an assigned transaction ID; both original patches and the subsequent horizon fix were committed #12.