model-writtenrun 8044 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Justin Pryzby proposed detecting leftover tablespace directories during pg_upgrade's checks, explaining that failed upgrades could leave directories that cause repeated failures after the new cluster is recreated #1.
- Justin refined the check to use the target cluster's tablespace suffix, handle unexpected stat errors, and report successful completion #2.
- Bruce Momjian reproduced the failure and verified the patch, then simplified path handling and naming; his revised submissions also incorporated Justin's explanation of why older tablespace layouts remain compatible with the check #3 #4 #5.
- Justin supplied a concrete PostGIS upgrade failure that left tablespace directories behind and prevented subsequent upgrade attempts #6.
- Bruce committed the early check from #5 with comment and whitespace corrections as 3c0471b5fd, backpatched it to supported versions, and clarified that Justin deserved authorship credit #7.
- Andres Freund reported that the loop's inline variable declaration broke compilation on older branches #8, prompting Bruce to move the declaration to function scope in 536de14e2b and confirm the repair #9.
- Justin then proposed a development-branch follow-up that would permit empty target tablespace directories during checking and remove them before restoring global objects, allowing some retries to succeed automatically #10.
- Tom Lane objected that removing and recreating directories could lose intended ownership or permissions and require parent-directory write access #11; Justin explained that CREATE TABLESPACE rejects existing version directories and argued for keeping the workaround within pg_upgrade #12.
- The thread ended with the early check and compatibility fix committed, while the empty-directory cleanup remained uncommitted after Bruce favored reporting an error over adding automatic repair complexity #13.