model-writtenrun 6156 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Hubert Zhang reported that a non-hot standby placed before a working primary prevented libpq failover in #1; Takayuki Tsunakawa proposed distinguishing server errors by SQLSTATE in #2, and Noah Misch pointed to an earlier discussion of the same bug in #3.
- Hubert and Hao Wu supplied #4, adding retries both for handshake read failures and for ERRCODE_CANNOT_CONNECT_NOW.
- Tom Lane argued in #6 that the three read-failure retries lacked supporting evidence, that CANNOT_CONNECT_NOW should bypass SSL/GSS retries, and that reliable accumulation and host attribution of errors were prerequisites for expanded failover.
- Tom implemented that broader design in #7, separating error accumulation, host-identifying error prefixes, and the retained SQLSTATE-based failover; broader retry behavior remained deliberately excluded.
- Variable socket paths made ECPG expected output unstable, so Tom added regression-output postprocessing in #8 and reported a successful check-world run; Hubert then identified an IPv6 delimiter bug in #9, which Tom agreed to fix in #10.
- The error-accumulation component of #8 landed as ffa2e46701, with literal-string append optimizations, translation-string cleanup, and formatting edits.
- The regression postprocessing component of #8 landed as 800d93f314, incorporating Hubert's delimiter correction; its expected-output updates moved into the host-identification commit 52a10224e3.
- The unchanged failover component of #8 landed as c1d589571c, crediting Hubert Zhang and reviewer Takayuki Tsunakawa.
- Justin Pryzby reported in #11 that leaving errorMessage populated after successful connections broke sqlsmith; Tom reconsidered preserving connection-attempt history in #12, while Michael Paquier and Daniel Gustafsson supported clearing the buffer in #15 and #16.
- Michael reported GSS-dependent ECPG failures on Windows in #19, where accumulated errors exposed a failed GSS attempt before the expected database error; Tom questioned why the credential-cache check permitted that attempt in #20.
- Michael proposed disabling GSS for the affected tests and noticed missing environment cleanup in #21, then supplied a separate TestLib.pm cleanup in #25; later discussion in #30 treated that environment cleanup as already committed.
- Tom's ECPG fix in #26 set PGGSSENCMODE inside the test, but Michael identified missing MSVC library dependencies in #27 and supplied a tested Windows revision in #29.
- Tom rejected globally replacing pgwin32_setenv because of memory leaks and questioned exposing internal portability headers to ECPG application tests in #30; Michael favored inline connection options in #31, and Tom suggested making default-target connections succeed in #32.
- Tom's replacement patch #33 renamed a role to match an existing database and retained one explicit failure with GSS disabled, but Michael's review in #34 exposed a conflict with regression role-naming rules.
- Tom abandoned the rename in #35; 9bb5eecce6 instead disabled the default-target failure case and added gssencmode=disable to the other case, with #36 leaving the underlying GSS credential behavior unresolved.
- Tom returned to the successful-connection compatibility issue in #37, concluding that the retained failure prefix was misleading and that useful connection-attempt tracing would require separate work; the attached buffer reset landed unchanged as 138531f1bb.
- Michael approved the final reset in #38 after it had already landed; the supplied candidates were all committed, while diagnosing the GSS credential behavior and designing useful connection-attempt tracing remained deferred.